Welcome Guest! The IOSH forums are a free resource to both members and non-members. Login or register to use them

Postings made by forum users are personal opinions. IOSH is not responsible for the content or accuracy of any of the information contained in forum postings. Please carefully consider any advice you receive.

Notification

Icon
Error

Options
Go to last post Go to first unread
AdrianW  
#1 Posted : 08 February 2023 16:22:27(UTC)
Rank: Forum user
AdrianW

I'm considering taking on associate consultancy work - midlands area.

Can anyone advise on what would be a reasonable daily £ rate?

Experience wise I have 25 years+ in the FM and Construction industries.

peter gotch  
#2 Posted : 09 February 2023 10:59:28(UTC)
Rank: Super forum user
peter gotch

Morning Adrian

Your thread has been read 80 times without reply which might indicate that your question is very difficult to answer.

I see all sorts of daily rates quoted. Some tiny, some huge, many in between.

You say that you have 25 years experience in construction and FM, but with no indication of what that experience has meant.

For all I know you could have spent 25 years installing fire alarms and may be an expert on how many fire alarms should be in a building, to what specification and in what locations - but you could offer very little value in terms of providing a broader range of H&S advisory services in construction, FM or beyond.

So, at the very least, you need to give the readers a better picture of your skills, knowledge and experience.

Ultimately, you need to consider how many hours a week (INCLUDING travelling and work at home, in hotels etc) you want to do and how much you want to earn per week, and assess how you sell yourself to the market for that amount or more, making sure that you include for expenses OR keep them separate from the daily rate.

AND you need to include for all the other costs that becoming a consultant may involve - so you might be spending more time at home and running up higher energy costs, you might want to pay an accountant, get in somebody to market you etc etc.

AND it may be entirely appropriate to set different rates according to the value of what you offering.

As example, I used to work for a major engineering consultancy - in general hourly rates were set based on the individual's annual salary (divided by circa 2000 hours per year) and then multiplied assuming a ball park of a multiplier of 2ish simply to break even (LOTS of backroom costs in a large organisation, you should have lesser such costs).

.....but then the bid team would consider how much ABOVE break even to be bidding at and the number would vary enormously AND of course the price included for at least part of the cost of actually putting together the bid (Win some, lose some, but the bid team have to be paid) 

So, on a huge contract, the multiplier would be set at fairly close to break even - high volume, low margin.

For niche work but a small contract, a MUCH high multiplier. For expert witness work or anything similar such that there is very little competition (so perhaps someone on the "ICE Panel" of reservoir engineers - no, I am not on that Panel!!), almost whatever number you choose..

AdrianW  
#3 Posted : 09 February 2023 13:03:18(UTC)
Rank: Forum user
AdrianW

Hi Peter

Thanks for your post, much appreciated.

My experience in FM has been that of an H&S Advisor supporting engineers carrying out M&E works in plantrooms etc, and as H&S Advisor employed with principal contractors on construction sites.

Ian Bell2  
#4 Posted : 14 February 2023 19:43:33(UTC)
Rank: Super forum user
Ian Bell2

Look at recruitment websites for short term contact rates. The add a percentage on top for business costs and additional profit.

For each £5/hr is about equivalent to a £10k annual salary increments.

Alternatively make use of an onine tax calculator - put in the salary you would like to earn to get an approximate Gross annual salary rate - most sites report figures interms of hourly/daily/weekly/monthly rates.

Then once again add in an allowance for business costs, pension contributions etc, profit.

Presumably you intend working for more than a basic salary plus cost. 

Mark-W  
#5 Posted : 21 February 2023 14:59:28(UTC)
Rank: Super forum user
Mark-W

You also need to look at if you want to make a huge profit or just tick over.

If you want to tick over then it's easaier, cost of company car, phone, new IT etc etc can all eat into your profit and reduce your tax liability.

Paying yourself do you want to be solely PAYE or small wage and then dividends. You need to speak to an accountant for this though.

Are you going Ltd company or sole trader. Both have benefits and drawbacks. Only you know the correct solution for you.

Are you going VAT registered? Despite not meeting the VAT threshold you can still opt to be registered.

I'm VAT registered but not meeting the threshold. Means my new company car is 20% cheaper and fuel is also 20% cheaper. 

Also are you going self employed for a better work'life balance? You need to understand the implications for not doing a 5 day week.

Ian Bell2  
#6 Posted : 22 February 2023 09:29:31(UTC)
Rank: Super forum user
Ian Bell2

The hardest part of any  1 man consultancy is getting the sales leads and/or associate work. Then there is the cash flow - from 1st contact enquiry to doing the work and finally getting paid can take many months. So cash flow is the issue. I would suggest that you need initial funds of at least 6months to live off, if you have no other work income.

firesafety101  
#7 Posted : 27 February 2023 17:00:48(UTC)
Rank: Super forum user
firesafety101

In my experience there is a lot of money to be made in construction but the high earners are usually many years experienced and seem to know everyone.

I started quite cheap and got to be recognised as a good safety adviser for a variey of sub contractors and earned their respect.  I now work for a few shopfitting companies, I drop the poor payers and the ones that ignore my advice but have built up my hourly rate.

It seems all on this group are reluctant to say what they earn, as am I, but if you start cheapish and build up the client base because you work well and get along, you can gradually increase yor rates.

Self and Hasty  
#8 Posted : 01 March 2023 14:18:23(UTC)
Rank: Forum user
Self and Hasty

As others have discussed; costing/pricing is completely subjective. 

In addition to the running cost considerations of the business detailed above I also consider what is involved with the job prior to quoting;

-The size, occupancy and use of the site; -The activities conducted and the associated hazards and risks from those activities; -Exisitng controls, systems, accreditation, documentation and the sites culture; -The distance from home and hours required on site; -Tasks and responsibilities of the contract; is it just a one-off risk assessment or a full audit of the companies systems? Is it just one report or continued ongoing support. 

As nobody else has stated what they charge I will; 

It's subject to change upon consideration of all of the above, but as a guide I charge £265 a day which includes a report/write up.

If the on-site inspection or the write-up takes me longer than a day (or is anticipated to) I increase my quote by £132.50 for every half-day anticipated/taken.

This is for me and my companies needs, this may not be suitable or sufficient for you and your business, or competitive compared to other professionals in your area.

I occassionally seek quotes from other professionals for works on behalf of clients, reviewing quotes gives me a good view of what others in my field and area are charging and I can adjust my prices accordingly.

I don't think being secretive about pricing or any aspect of contracting work is helpful for anyone when we're all in the same boat. Sharing this information takes nothing from me nor my company, but may be beneficial for others, it would be better if other people shared.

Thanks

Scusack  
#9 Posted : 01 March 2023 15:04:03(UTC)
Rank: Forum user
Scusack

I'm putting all of this in as a discussion point, I'm sure there are plenty of people who will hold contrary positions.

There are many variables when it comes to charging, and it often helps to be flexible.  Large companies can sometimes afford to pay more than small ones, geography and industry sector is also a factor.  Some of my competitors charge more than £1,000 per day, but they work for the big companies with massive overheads.  Others charge less than £300, but they're typically small/single operators.

Other factors to take into account.

1. Member of OSHCR? Y/N.

2. Qualifications (Masters / Degree / Diploma / Cert / IOSH Managing Safely / University of life).

3. Professional status (CFIOSH / CMIOSH / Grad IOSH / other organisation).

4. Area of expertise (Niche/specialist or bog-standard risk assessment and safety inspections).

5. Industry contacts (clients often employ people they already know, or have been recommended).

6. Quality of your website (attracting clients).

7. Web presence and advertising levels.

8. Sole trader or Ltd company.

9. Mobility (will travel?).

10. Quality of your written work (professional looking, grammatically correct, spell checked, etc.).

11. Experienced in the field being quoted for (instills confidence).

12. Knowing when to say no (don't be a cowboy).

13. Duration of the project - a 3 month contract means you could charge a lower daily rate than a 1 day job (mind out for IR35 though).

As has been mentioned, being VAT registered can be very helpful - lowers some of your own running costs and makes you look more professional.

How much to charge?  In the early days I plucked a (in my opinion) reasonable figure.  If they said yes straightaway my wife told me I was too cheap.  If they look like they're trying to lay an ostrich egg then I follow it up with a "however I am negotiable".  That way you will get a feel for how much to quote in the future.  Am I going to tell you how much I charge? All I will say is that it is (significantly) less than £1k but more than £300/day.

thanks 1 user thanked Scusack for this useful post.
Self and Hasty on 02/03/2023(UTC)
Ian Bell2  
#10 Posted : 04 March 2023 07:19:12(UTC)
Rank: Super forum user
Ian Bell2

£265 day is ridiculously low in my opinion, Even if you work every day - 5day/week for 47 weeks a year is a turnover of circa £62k. Then less business costs.

If you have other income, fair enough

Most consultants don't wotk every day, maybe2/3rds to 3/4 of available days. I don't charge £1k day, but certainly much more than £265

OCHR membership is pointless/never asked for

IOSH membership is irrelevant to my area of safety consultancy

peter gotch  
#11 Posted : 04 March 2023 13:54:48(UTC)
Rank: Super forum user
peter gotch

Hi Adrian

One of the other critical variables is how long it is going to take you to write up any visit.

Some consultants do tick box exercises such that perhaps it only takes a couple of hours to write up a day's visit.

Others may need to go away do some thinking and quite easily take two or three days to write up the report of a one day visit. Even longer in some circumstances, e.g. when doing an Expert Witness report.

So, often a "daily rate" may be a sub-optimal way of charging a client.. 

Mark-W  
#12 Posted : 06 March 2023 09:58:45(UTC)
Rank: Super forum user
Mark-W

Originally Posted by: Self and Hasty Go to Quoted Post

As others have discussed; costing/pricing is completely subjective. 

As nobody else has stated what they charge I will; 

It's subject to change upon consideration of all of the above, but as a guide I charge £265 a day which includes a report/write up.

If the on-site inspection or the write-up takes me longer than a day (or is anticipated to) I increase my quote by £132.50 for every half-day anticipated/taken.

I'm a smidgen more than that but it's what I'm happy charging. I only work 3 days a week. I'm not going to die a millionairre but I'm not going to die poor either.

I have some regular clients who I visit weekly, some fortnightly and some monthly and some as and when the work comes in. 

I never work a Friday, due to having a minor stroke a few years ago when my work/life balance was completely wrong. So a revamp of my lifestyle and now I'm happy and content.

I've just changed my company car so now have a vehicle that will hopefully last me until I retire, whenever that will be. 

Whilst I said that being VAT registered works for me, you have to be aware it only works if you are working for VAT registered companies or you become 20% dearer than other small consultant companys.

Heres a question for other consultants though. Travel time, do you include that in your day or not or a bit of it?

For my clients I visit weekly, I travel in my time to and from, but if I'm doing site visits for them, all my travel time is on the clock. 

peter gotch  
#13 Posted : 06 March 2023 15:18:16(UTC)
Rank: Super forum user
peter gotch

Hi Mark - charging for travel time?

A commercial decision.

If you live in say Southampton and have a client in Newcastle, if you charge travel time you probably won't be competitive unless you can offer something that adds value to the client that some local consultant can't provide.

Some decades ago we were asked to run a specific training course in the Falkland Islands. We priced on the basis that if the delegates were going to get best benefit from a 4 day course, it needed more than one trainer - partly to up the one to one superision when the delegates were split into groups for case study work -  AND we charged not only for travel time but also for recuperation time after the travel in each direction. We got the job and I guess that if we were in competition the other bidders were probably taking a similar approach (though I guess that some would have offered a single trainer).

For another client, we charged nearly a day's travel time in each direction. So, if they bought back to back courses in the same week, it was obviously much more cost effective than just buying a single course.

However, the price of the external consultant is much less than the cost of taking X delegates off their day jobs for however long a course lasts or the time they spend with the consultant doing a risk assessment or whatever.

So, if you can show that you will add value, the client probably won't be too bothered about paying for your travel time.

markspeaking62  
#14 Posted : 09 March 2023 16:53:35(UTC)
Rank: New forum user
markspeaking62

I've been following this conversation with interest as I'm currently battling with the decision whether to become a self employed H&S Advisor having been the Company's H&S Manager for 18 years and the named "Competent Advisor " as per MHSWR Reg 7. 

So any guidance in pointing me to another source to discuss this with, directly would be very helpful. I apologise for changing the thread of the conversation mid stream and I will continue to follow as the subject of charging is significant.

Does anybody have any comments about Contracts of Service for a Competent Advisor that you provide and whether there is an income to be made from these?

Kate  
#15 Posted : 09 March 2023 17:34:24(UTC)
Rank: Super forum user
Kate

Mark, I recommend this IOSH Consultancy Group webinar entitled "Is consultancy right for me?":

(Crikey, I pasted the link and it turned into an image, I wasn't expecting that!)

Edited by user 09 March 2023 17:35:51(UTC)  | Reason: Crikey ...

thanks 5 users thanked Kate for this useful post.
peter gotch on 09/03/2023(UTC), chris42 on 10/03/2023(UTC), Scusack on 17/03/2023(UTC), sevans62 on 05/04/2023(UTC), Mark-W on 06/09/2023(UTC)
Scusack  
#16 Posted : 17 March 2023 10:06:19(UTC)
Rank: Forum user
Scusack

Really interesting Kate, thanks for posting that.  I see that it refers to being careful not to waste money on unnecessary advertising.  My experience has been the same (advertising is often a necessary evil, but you must get it right). As a member of the OSHCR I only get something like 2 referrals a year through that route.  I have spent ages writing, refining and re-refining my Google advert to get it as narrowly targetted as possible to avoid wasting money.  It take me 5-10 minutes a day to review the metrics on the Google Analytics and the Google Ads apps, attend to the housekeeping of the advert (location, key words, exclusions, accessibility on various media).  Everytime I fix an issue, Google seems to change the rules, or worse still ignore the rules already established - grrrr! On average I get one or two calls a month through the Google Ad, of which typically only one call is of any value.  Each advert click (normally by someone using an unrelated key word in the North of Scotland or Isle of Man, despite my filters) costs circa £5-£8 each. My other calls just come via "normal" Google.  Google advertising costs me anything between £80-£100 per month (I set a cap), and I don't run it all year round.  If you're not highly IT literate I would suggest you avoid Google Ads, but your decision.

Edited by user 17 March 2023 10:10:15(UTC)  | Reason: Typo correction

thanks 1 user thanked Scusack for this useful post.
Kate on 17/03/2023(UTC)
Users browsing this topic
You cannot post new topics in this forum.
You cannot reply to topics in this forum.
You cannot delete your posts in this forum.
You cannot edit your posts in this forum.
You cannot create polls in this forum.
You cannot vote in polls in this forum.