Welcome Guest! The IOSH forums are a free resource to both members and non-members. Login or register to use them

Postings made by forum users are personal opinions. IOSH is not responsible for the content or accuracy of any of the information contained in forum postings. Please carefully consider any advice you receive.

Notification

Icon
Error

Options
Go to last post Go to first unread
Admin  
#1 Posted : 23 February 2009 16:39:00(UTC)
Rank: Guest
Admin

Posted By JJ
Our operatives working on utility type jobs require a common set of workwear which protects against 1) Electric Arc Flash (if striking electricity cables) and 2) Electrostatic (if striking and igniting gas pipes).

I realise there are 2 seperate standards (BS EN 61482 and BS EN 1149 respectively), but will either one give protection against the other ?

If not, is there another standard which will protect against both arc flash AND electrostatic build up ?

Thanking you in anticipation.

JJ
Admin  
#2 Posted : 23 February 2009 18:04:00(UTC)
Rank: Guest
Admin

Posted By Dave Merchant
No, but there are several fabrics which are certified to both standards, such as Carrington's Flamestat.
Admin  
#3 Posted : 02 March 2009 21:15:00(UTC)
Rank: Guest
Admin

Posted By Elaina Harvey
check out www.arcflashprotection.co.uk

Everything you need to know is on this website, they can also provide PPE after you have completed your risk assessment.

Some useful information:

As we know heat from an electric arc is an important hazard that workers need to be protected from. Once end users have carried out their own risk assessment and if they have identified as a result of this to provide their workforce with FR protective clothing, there are new standards and test methods that they can refer to

Clothing is subject to norm IEC 61482-2/CDV. In order to choose adequate protective clothing, the potential incident heat energy (in units of energy per square surface) caused by an electric arc and to which a worker may be exposed, needs to be calculated in this thorough risk assessment.

Within the garment standard, the norm refers to fabrics that can be tested to "open arc", covered by IEC 61482-1, or "arc in a box" covered by IEC 61482-1-2

Quantifying the arc rating of a protective garment
1. The arc rating is most commonly quantified by the ARC THERMAL PERFORMANCE VALUE (ATPV) determined by the open arc test method IEC 61482-1. This test method is currently being revised to IEC 61482-1-1/FDIS. The ATPV represents the [B]maximum incident thermal energy in units of energy per surface area (e.g. kJ/m2 or cal/cm2) that a fabric can support before the wearer will suffer 2nd degree burns.

The break-open threshold energy (or EBT) is another fabric characteristic. It represents the highest incident energy exposure value on a fabric where the garments do not exhibit break-open. The formation of holes in the fabric caused by break-opne would allow heat or flames to pass through. Workers are assumed safe if the arc rating of their clothing (or ATPV value)exceeds the electric arc incident energy as calculated in the worst case scenario of a risk assessment.

THIS TEST IS SIMILAR TO ASTM F 1959

2. The box test is another way to measure the protective performance of clothing against the thermal effects of an electric arc and is defined in the IEC 61482-1-2 test method. In this test, the fabric is exposed to an electric arc confined in a specific box with a specific electrode arrangement.
Class 1
Arc Duration= 0.5s Arc Current = 4kA
Class 2
Arc Duration= 0.5s Arc Current = 7kA

A fabric passes the test:
- if the heat transferred behind the fabric does not cause second degree burn (i.e. is below the Stoll curve)
- if the after flame time is below 5 seconds
- if there is no melting to the inner side of the fabric
- if a hole caused by the arc is not larger than 5 mm in every direction (in the inner most layer).

Test conditions for Class 1 try to simulate typical exposure conditions for a short circuit current of 4 kA protected by devises limited the duration of the arc to 0.5 seconds in confined space, and of 7 kA respectively for Class 2.

(To be used in Low Voltage Systems only)

DuPont TM Arc-Man(r)
This equipment developed by DuPont measures the ATPV value of protective fabrics and garments in simulated open electric arc incidents. It exposes the materials to energy levels of up to 70 cal/cm2 (for information, continuous exposure to 1.2 cal/cm2 may be enough to cause a 2nd degree burn on human skin generated by an open arc).

Incident energy is calculated on several parameters influencing an electric arc, such as current, duration of the arc, electrode material, the gap between the electrodes and the distance of the tested fabrics or garments to the arc.

Arc-Man(r) can test fabrics on panels, measuring the ATPV value of the fabric system (in cal/cm2) so that it can be compared with the incident energy calculated in the end user's risk assessment. Arc-Man(r) can also perform complementary garment tests on a torso to show the effect of a garment's design and integrity of manufacture, allowing an assessment of the garment's behaviour (e.g. of the closure system, the pockets, etc.).

The box test according to IEC 61482-1-2 (equivalent to EN 61482-1-2) can also be performed on DuPont TM Arc-Man(r) testing facility.

ARC-MAN(r) IS SIMILAR TO KINECTRICS TEST FACILITY

Recommendations

- DuPont recommends that all layers are made of inherently flame resistant materials
- inappropriate underwear could ignite or melt, thus having an adverse effect on protection aggravating the outcome of an electric arc incident
- Nomex(r) offers single layer and multi-layer protective clothing solutions against electric arc hazards, conforming to IEC 61482-2 when tested according to IEC 61482-1 (Open arc incidents) and IEC 61482-1-2 (Arc in a Box or confined arc incidents).

Electric arc protective clothing can receive IEC 61482-2/CDV certification if one of the following requirements are met:
- the ATPV value of the clothing must be at least 4 cal/cm2
- the clothing has to pass at least the electric arc box Class 1.

DuPont recommends to the user to ask weavers and garment manufacturers for an offering of fabrics, fabric systems and garments, which meet his or her specific arc rating needs and also his needs of other important properties in the best combination. Our NQP weavers, knitters and garment manufacturers can provide you with tested and certified solutions.

Some Contacts at NQP Weavers

Estambril
Toni Medina - Area Manager
Mobile: +34 638 121257
E-Mail: t.medina@estambril.com

Frische
Göschel Hans
E-Mail: goeschel@tfritsche.de
Mobile: +49 9252 99050


Fuchshuber (Knitter)
Tel.: +49 (0)7129/6915-16
Fax: +49 (0)7129/6915-15
Email: b.roth@fttex.com


Ibena
Britta Smeulders - Technical Manager
Tel: +49/(0)2871/287-131
FAX: +49/(0)2871/287-130
Mobil: +49/(0)174/3426021
E-Mail: britta.smeulders@ibena.de

Sofileta
Colin Clark
Tel: +44 7827 966599
Email: cclark_sofileta@btinternet.com


Distributor/Garment Manufacturers

J & K Ross
Chris Ross
Mobile: +44 780 2558995
Email: cross@jkross.co.uk
www.arcflashprotection.co.uk

Iturri
Carlos Gálvez
0034 6075 19101
Email: cgalvez@textulan.net

Sioen
Andrew Braimbridge
Tel: +44 7976 103790
E-mail: Andrew.Braimbridge@uk.sioen.com

Wenaas
Jim Hanna
Mobile: +44 7866 559860
Email: Jim.Hanna@wenaas.co.uk

I'd be delighted to respond to your queries further

Elaina Harvey
Nomex(r) UK Account Manager
+44 7881 836588
elaina.harvey@gbr.dupont.com
Admin  
#4 Posted : 02 March 2009 21:31:00(UTC)
Rank: Guest
Admin

Posted By Elaina Harvey
A PPE protecting against static build up is subject to norm EN 1149-5. Electrostatic discharge (ESD) can lead to generation of sparks with energy levels sufficient to ignite possible surrounding vapours, aerosols of flammable liquids or dust particles, and cause ignition and explosion.

DuPont developed a Nomex® fibre blend using an antistatic fibre P-140. This is a permanent antistatic carbon core polyamide fibre which helps fabrics made with Nomex® to quickly dissipate static electricity that could
have built up on the fabric through rubbing on another non-conductive surface.
P-140 is included in the Nomex® solutions:
Nomex® Comfort and Nomex® IIIA
Nomex® MetalPro, Nomex® MetalPro Plus
Nomex® Tough

Garments made of these materials are tested in accordance to EN 1149-3 and
fulfil the electrostatic protection requirements of EN 1149-5 for
protective clothing.
Such garments are safe, as long as the limitations of use given in EN
1149-5 are observed, which are:
1) material and design requirements for electrostatic dissipative protective clothing, used as part of a total earthed system, to avoid incendiary discharges. The requirements may not be sufficient in oxygen enriched flammable atmospheres. This standard is not applicable for protection against mains voltage.

2)The material and design requirements as specified in the Eu standard apply only to electrostatic dissipative clothing worn by persons that are earthed through a resistance lower than 10 to power 8 ohms 9e.g. by wearing appropriate footwear such as safety shoes specified in en iso 20345:2004, or by any other suitable means). The requirements of this standard are not intended to be applied for static dissipative gloves. For these gloves, the electrical resistance through the material is an important property.


In Europe solutions made from Nomex® Comfort tend to be worn in the industrial markets for protection against electrical arc and flash fire and therefore fulfil the requirements of EN 1149-5.

For flash fire/electric arc, clothing made from Nomex(r)Comfort has permanent antistatic properties built in and therefore can be worn in these hazards to provide multi-risk protection.

The garment manufacturers/distributors on my previous response as well as other Nomex(r)garment manufactuers can provide further details. Please also contact me for additional information if required.

Elaina Harvey
UK Nomex(r)Account Manager
+44 7881 836588
elaina.harvey@gbr.dupont.com
Users browsing this topic
Guest
You cannot post new topics in this forum.
You cannot reply to topics in this forum.
You cannot delete your posts in this forum.
You cannot edit your posts in this forum.
You cannot create polls in this forum.
You cannot vote in polls in this forum.