Rank: Super forum user
|
I'll second the comments made by stuff4blokes
|
|
|
|
Rank: Forum user
|
An interesting reply from IOSH, all very good us members getting benefit from it but no reason as to why costs are so high. I don't think it represents good value for money, and the IOSH rail safety conference later this month at a quarter the cost looks better value for money (only if in rail sector though....).
There are some really good points here about what we get for our money:
1. Many expert presenters are free (their profile improves and share knowledge about their industry/area).
2. IOSH employees wages are/should be covered elsewhere.
3. The costs remaining revolve around the venue, catering, materials, advertising etc.
4. Income generating: Firms and businesses pay for doing the trade fair, and sponsoring certain aspects.
A potential president elect could/should see this as an election issue, I will vote for the person who can commit to delivering the 'austerity' IOSH conference for us. I really think we could/should get most of the benefits for a significantly reduced cost.
|
|
|
|
Rank: Forum user
|
Every year, we offer 500 free or low cost (below £100) events for members, and last year, thousands of members took advantage of these
Hmmm - how can 'thousands of members' benefit from 500 free/low cost events last year???
Anyway, I would love to attend but £645 is too much for me. Added to this are costs for accommodation, meals and getting to/from the venue. Oh yes, having to take 3 days off work too adds to the cost. I suspect one will not have any change from £1,000.
|
|
|
|
Rank: Forum user
|
I wonder (for a smallfee)could we get access to it on the internet,?
it would allow more to benefit from it,
|
|
|
|
Rank: Super forum user
|
Ian, thanks for A response?
Firstly, from one of your first statements, how did thousands of members take advantage of
500 free or low cost (below £100) events for members….?
Next as has already been stated, many of the speakers are unpaid?
Next, we are still in a very difficult economic climate, how do you expect individuals on low wages and unemployed persons who are professional members of IOSH and have supported the Institution in membership fees for decades expected to pay these high corporate rates…?
Next, without all the membership fees pouring-in and the often unpaid work conducted voluntarily by H&S professionals IOSH would not exist as it does currently.
Ian, a reality check is required here!
You have shown a total disregard to the very people who keep the Institution in business in the first place.
|
|
|
|
Rank: Forum user
|
I've no doubt the conference would represent an excellent opportunity to network and participate in some quality discussions and achieve some real 'learning outcomes'. It still does not, however, represent a cost that most can afford. I suspect that may be the plan. No point in overcrowding the venue, meaning a poor experience for all as 'peer to peer round table discussions' becomes oversubscribed with standing room only.......
So, we are left with an artificially high price tag, knowing this will limit attendance to corporate sponsors or the wealthy and the stock 'corporate response' from IOSH defending its position. Leaving the majority of members frustrated and annoyed at being treated this way and venting our frustrations on a web page.
Its not a conference - its a lucky-people-only-club and we are not invited.
|
|
|
|
Rank: Super forum user
|
How about free passes for technical grade safety professionals who are currently out of work…..?
|
|
|
|
Rank: Forum user
|
Speaking as a non-member who is not really interested in attending funny handshake events I think rather than coming on here and having a bit of a bleat about the cost of the event it is up to the members to take direct action. If you don't agree with the cost do something about it. I'd be willing to bet that if no action is taken (and I don't mean a bit of a forum protest) then the same thing will be repeated again next year.
|
|
|
|
Rank: Super forum user
|
I'm not currently a member of IOSH either, not sure yet if work will pay my subs or not or whether i'll have to pay myself but i know they wouldn't think about paying for the conference side.
However, the exhibition is free with exhibitors along the lines of who turn up at the NEC in May and since i have a depot in Walthamstow i might make a visit.
On a side note anyone know if the IOSH extras is any good (if i have to pay the subs myself...)
|
|
|
|
Rank: Super forum user
|
Firstly an apology – I have been remiss in not answering more promptly. I am very sorry about that but like many of you I have to balance the voluntary duties with my work.
Secondly - a thank you, for your time and considered posts. You should be aware they are being taken note of but please do not expect knee jerk reactions to every comment made. As your next President and Chair of the IOSH 2011 Working Party I think it is my responsibility to offer my thoughts on the posts so far.
This is a thorny issue every year. Contrary to opinions, this year is no different to some who may have been on hard times last year, the year before or the year before that etc. Although the recession will undoubtedly affect a lot of us this year/next, we simply cannot drop the standard of conference we have worked hard to develop.
As the world’s largest body of safety professionals we have to offer an event that befits our status. Putting on such a large event introduces logistical restrictions as well as expectations. These come at a price.
One focus that continues to be at the centre of the development process is member access to ‘our’ (yes that means you) event, so that all who wish to come, can - in some way or other.
I fully respect decisions and difficulties resulting in non attendance, but please see what is available to you rather than issue a simple ‘won’t go’ statement.
We are suggesting various ways in which Networks can make this easier for members. We are also using technology to bring conference to you- in different ways, but with sensible cost limits. This will increase in the future but I trust you will understand we have to draw the budget line somewhere.
The Conference Working Party consists of IOSH members as well as staff and the conference provider. You have my assurance that you – as potential delegates, were in the front of our minds at every step of development.
The IOSH conference is one activity in the membership calendar – it happens to be our biggest and our flagship event. We attract members from all grades and sectors, industry influencers, VIP’s and a host of others from the UK and far beyond. This event makes IOSH a global brand which in turn reaps benefits to its membership.
If it isn’t for you, for one reason or another, then fine. There are plenty of other IOSH activities you can go to. But please understand that a lot of people enjoy going, have the means to support this CPD activity in their control and see it as a very well spent 2 days. I am sure there are a lot of people who are looking forward to it – whether full attendees, single session only delegates or simply free exhibition attendees.
I am sure there will be more said and hope the discussion looks at both sides of the coin.
Steve
|
|
|
|
Rank: Forum user
|
Steve maybe part of the other side of the coin!
Dear All
Some posts here are a puzzle. When Ian was talking value for money, maybe this might have been in his mind:
IOSH 2011: £322.80 per day – member early rate: Each day includes Key speakers + 4 workshop streams per day x 3 individual sessions to each stream + a fifth workshop to be decided by contributors [you if you want] by accessing the conference website up till the 7th January 2011 + panel discussion + exhibition + spotlight theatres [attend free sessions] + IOSH Network theatre + networking opportunities + one massive amount of organising.
As with the previous year, the conference organisers consulted with some previous conference delegates and feedback from this year’s conference to set out an agenda shaped by IOSH members.
This year:
IOSH: 800 delegates, 1,300 visitors and over 100 exhibitors and one massive amount of organising.
ROSPA Scotland 1 day Annual Conference 1 hour less than IOSH day: £217.50 2 workshops morning and afternoon.
Croner 1 day Annual Conference: £290.00
IOSH Rail 1 day Conference this month: £182.13 2 workshops morning and afternoon
HSW/IISM 1 day Conference: £351.00
By the time the different formats, amount of workshops speakers etc are gone through, the fee does not appear to be out of line with what is being offered by other health and safety conferences.
Living in one of the highest unemployment centres in the UK – I live in the North East - and having learnt last week two of my close relatives have both just been made redundant things are not exactly bouyant up here. So I do appreciate the situation for those where money is tight.
However with all the opportunities at branch level, networking, knowing IOSH members etc, it should not be too hard to find out what all the presenters were saying without going to the conference.
In the past I have found the conference very useful. I have no doubt the one in 2011 will be when I attend it as well.
Cheers.
Nigel
|
|
|
|
Rank: Super forum user
|
Steve, the reason it’s a thorny issue each year is because very little is done to assist the very members that do struggle to afford the rates that have been set!
I’ glad you respect decisions and difficulties resulting in non attendance, maybe this should be placed firmly at the top of 2012 agenda?
Many professionals would love to actually attend - but they cannot afford it…?
I find your comments coming across as little more than indifference.
The many colleagues that I talk to don’t want a different way of learning from these events (technology), they want to attend these events, but again cannot afford it!
I have been in the safety profession for nearly two decades, I’ve not seen the reaps of benefits you mention from this annual events, please explain?
|
|
|
|
Rank: Super forum user
|
Apologies for my spelling mistakes in last commentary!
|
|
|
|
Rank: Super forum user
|
Steve/Nigel,
Bearing in mind many of those occupied in this industry are consultants, despite what others may think, we are not overly well paid. Taking time off work (assuming you have some) travelling cost and having to pay £322.80 per day – member early rate, does appear to be very expensive to me. Why does the IOSH rail conference cost £182, nearly half the price?
Ray
|
|
|
|
Rank: Super forum user
|
I’d like to see more done for people on low incomes and people who are unemployed and members of this Institution.
IOSH could do much more to help these members, hope your listening…..?
|
|
|
|
Rank: Super forum user
|
I attended our local branch meeting this afternoon and one lucky attendee won a ticket for the conference, picked out by a random number.
No squeals of delight however especially as he was reminded that he had to make his own way there with no travel expenses reimbursed.
|
|
|
|
Rank: Super forum user
|
Hi Freelance, I can assure you that if it was indifference to people I would not have replied. I take representing the membership very seriously.
As far as doing more - tell me what you suggest. We have come up with the following;
• free access to the exhibition
• free access to some of the sessions
• free access to some of the information
• open discussion using multi media
• Facilitating discussion areas
• Networking opportunities
I am sure there are more.
Yes there is a fee to those who want al the frills but we are offering different pricing structures to suit different budgets this year.
and we are still listening……
Steve
|
|
|
|
Rank: Super forum user
|
Steve, I’ve made my points and ideas known and commented on yours?
Maybe YOU need to take on board what ALL the people have said so far and make sure that change happens for those that are less fortunate than others and as YOU have already stated;
“it’s a thorny issue each year”
It doesn’t have to be Steve.
|
|
|
|
Rank: Forum user
|
I like the last two paragraphs and with that information why would anyone pay to a very large amount for two days ...over priced and out of touch with the majority of the memebership
|
|
|
|
Rank: Forum user
|
i like the last two paragraphs..armed with that informatiom why would anyone pay such a lrage amount to attend ( igot a holiday for two in cyprus for a week for that)....over priced and out of touch with the majority of the membership
|
|
|
|
Rank: Forum user
|
Dear All
OK - with the way a conference of this size is organised having a debate about low cost/free entry for 37,396 members once the agenda has been set, speakers invited, budget allocation is made etc perhaps it is - maybe - a little late to change anything now. However looking at 2012, we might have time in which something could be done.
Free attendance means the organisation takes a 'hit' on the budget. To counteract this, the annual subsidy to the membership fee [£73.03 in the 2009/10 IOSH accounts] could be abolished thus leaving £2,729,908 available to spend. This should be able to pay members expenses as well and accommodation. If we put a maximum limit on travel expenses at £150.00 and a hotel for two nights out [would people need a subsistence allowance as well?] for £200.00 this should give the opportunity for 8,800 members to go free with expenses.
So if we put the fees up next year by £73 and have no subsidy, the points raised by the 35 people posting [0.0009359% of the membership, assuming all are members] on this thread could not only be addressed in full but present a great opportunity to open up the conference to a much larger group of members.
Hence this time, Chris, when members are given their free tickets 'squeals of delight' should eminate throughout the land because expenses will be paid as well.
A charge for non-members would be made, of course.
Any supporters?
Cheers.
Nigel
|
|
|
|
Rank: Super forum user
|
NigelB; my CMI annual fees are £10 per year more than my IOSH fees; as far as I am aware this is not subsidised by the revenue gained from the annual conference.
Although I did mention free tickets in my earlier post; I truly did not expect free attendance for all (which I suspect none of the other posters really feel would be practical? - sorry folks if that is what you really felt!). I support a conference with a reasonable (to me the 'ordinary' working man) cost, in a sensible location, that allows us mere mortals to attend the flagship event of OUR organisation. I do not think that the special offer of £645 is reasonable.
With my cynical head on - I suspect IOSH have to 'subsidise' our annual fees because the 'true' cost would be so unpalatable to the majority of members that numbers would drastically reduce?
Does IOSH publicise the fact that any fee paying non members of IOSH that attend the conference; are subsidising our annual fees?
Another well known if less numerous in members (?) and gravitas safety organisation; offered me full membership for fees at a lot less cost than the current subsidised fees, that I choose to pay for IOSH membership; maybe that will change in the future who knows?
Stuie
|
|
|
|
Rank: Super forum user
|
Thinking about it the other way - if we as members chose as an option (like we do with groups ) when renewals become due,to pay the £73 'subsidy' for our membership ourselves; could we then attend the conference for free :-)???? £73 is a lot mare palatable than £600+!
|
|
|
|
Rank: Super forum user
|
I’m sure most of the corporate entities will have no problem paying the fees.
However, a lot more could and SHOULD be done for the low paid and unemployed members that have supported our Institution for years, in the good times and now the very lean times.
Let’s be clear; IOSH is a charity and this should begin with the people who are members of this Institution.
For the recent ‘glossy brochure’ talk by a very small minority, we must remember that without all the health and safety professional IOSH would not exist as it currently does.
Actions Speak Louder Than Words.
|
|
|
|
Rank: Guest
|
It is more than obvious from Ian Smart and Steve Granger's replies that the IOSH EVENT OF THE YEAR is not aimed at the general membership.
They both go on about all the other events etc some costing less than £100.
This event could be construed as the Annual general Meeting and no company that I know of charges any fee to attend let alone such exhorbitant fees imposed by IOSH.
Let's be clear about this: the higher echelons of IOSH are hiding behind the smoke screen of all the "other events" held during the year. This is just plain insulting and does not answer the question: "justify the cost of this event"
The higher echelons should be brutally honest and admit that the event is all PR and not for the benefit of members.
I hope both Steve Granger and Ian Smart enjoy their "free" attendance.
Rich
|
|
|
|
Rank: Super forum user
|
Ian
Accept what you are saying, BUT, going back to the original post, most members CANNOT afford to pay out of their own pocket the price of conference and overnight accommodation (to make the most of the money spent). Plus, apart from the big companies who can afford to sub their employees, a larger proportion of companies these days are SME's with a small workforce who are just keeping their heads above water. So branch presentations aside those sme's will not receive info updates that may be vital to them.
Badger
|
|
|
|
Rank: Super forum user
|
Hi all,
I have been following this with great interest, I understand that IOSH want to keep this event to the same standards, but I still can't understand their maths.
Lets say that they drop the price a little to around the 300 quid mark, now surely the extra delegates that could attend would more than make up for the shortfall. Just a simple example:
@ 640 quid x 1000 delegates = 640000
@ 320 quid x 2000 delegates = 640000
I know the figures are simple, but it's simple maths.......
I don't want to be cynical but I just can't shake the image that the high price is to drive down the number of delegates, leaving it to the elite.
Oh and another thing.... if my professional body want to hold a conference, then I would like to be a part of the whole thing, not just a FREE trade show....... I can get one of thise through google at any time..
Rant Over... Have a nice day :)
|
|
|
|
Rank: Super forum user
|
I'm in agreement with everyone else who think that the upper echelons of IOSH have completely lost touch with reality. The benefits from the annual conference simply do not equate with the costs. I thought that we were all supposed to be familiar with the concept of "reasonably practicable"?
I am aware that some professional institutions have begun to make video recordings of conferences and seminars and, for a modest fee, sell DVDs to those who cannot attend.
It is time to either make the annual conference affordable for those who wish to attend or scrap the idea completely. It is clear from this and other postings that the majority of members are wholly dissatisfied with the status quo.
PH2
|
|
|
|
Rank: Forum user
|
I’m new to safety but fully conversant with certain other similar organisations.
My views tend to go beyond the one dimensional, it’s clear to me having read all the threads that IOSH is creating a closed shop – you’re either in the club or you are not!
I have seen many who have successful consultancies and use the body that they then represent to promote their business interests – many members are not ignorant of this.
To the minority of individuals; you have to honestly answer the question – who do you represent….?
|
|
|
|
Rank: Super forum user
|
I think that the assumption that large corporate bodies will happily pay their people to attend may well be wrong in this time of austerity. Department have budgets that are being squeezed and individuals within those departments have their own targets to achieve.
When I was a (small) budget holder in a large corporate body I had to justify the expenditure of sending people on what were perceived to be non-productive activities, not only to satisfy myself that I was using the time & money wisely, but also to the individuals who were being denied the opportunity to earn fees and so reach their financial targets. The result was that very few attended these big events. And that was in profitable times!
In my present happily self-employed situation, my decison has been very quick and simple. However, I am coming round to the opinion that if IOSH can put on a successful annual money-making event that subsidises my membership fees, I'll happily make do with the lower-key local events, seminars, exhibitions and meetings that are affordable, keep my CPD ticking over and even sometimes enjoyable.
Perhaps when the HSE register is up and running (I approve), their cartoon myth of moneybags consultants will become a fact (I live in hope) and I can then ask the driver to drop me off at the main entrance and whisk me back to the helipad when I become bored (I also fantasize a lot).
|
|
|
|
Rank: Forum user
|
Maybe its me being cynical but i personally dont think the event is aimed at the "workers" within health and safety.
Could it be a PR exercise to draw in the people who will be instrumental in the progression/development of the consultancy register and give ISOH a platform to lobby for the "contract " . comments on page 7 SHP.
I am all for professional satndards and progression.....but as a paying member of IOSH i want to be carried along not dragged..or worse told that is how its going to be.
And on the conference why not make it free...then you can select which events you wish to attend and pay for them accordingly.
|
|
|
|
Rank: Super forum user
|
It amazes me how IOSH is moving at a glacial pace on the issue……..?
It speaks volumes!
|
|
|
|
Rank: Forum user
|
PH2
You say 'It is clear from this and other postings that the majority of members are wholly dissatisfied with the status quo.'
Could you post the evidence of the views of the 37,396 members who have not posted on this thread which led you to your opinion? Is there a survey showing the details?
Any supporters for my proposal for a free conference for up to 8,800 members yet?
Cheers.
Nigel
|
|
|
|
Rank: Super forum user
|
I’m up for that.
I would also like to see IOSH actually take the lead and state that any unemployed member of this charitable status Institution may gain entry to any part of IOSH 2011 free of any charge, with the hope that this may assist them in gaining employment again.....?
|
|
|
|
Rank: Super forum user
|
How many of the 800 delegates that NigelB quotes last year were members of IOSH; and I wonder how many paid out of their own pocket?
I also wonder how many more members would attend the conference if the fees were reasonable and the location was more central; this increasing of attendance would have the effect of boosting the IOSH coffers further allowing an even bigger reduction in our annual fees - or is that too simplistic a view to take?
Maybe as others have put forward IOSH don't want us 'minions' (who incidentally are members on an equal footing and pay our fees the same as everyone else) to attend THEIR flagship event?
Cynical Stuie
|
|
|
|
Rank: Forum user
|
|
|
|
|
Rank: Forum user
|
I attended the IOSH conference in Glasgow last year, this was my first time. I am a member of IOSH. I will not be attending this years event, this is not due to the cost as my company is more than willing to pay for the entire event including accomodation and food.
If I had to pay myself this would be a different matter.
The main reason for my non attendance this year is due to the terrible organisation of last years conference. I found this to be abysmal for an event that is touted as a "world class, showcase event".
I did give my views on this via a telephone interview with IOSH last April.
Good luck to those who do attend but in my opinion it is definately NOT worth the asking price.
|
|
|
|
Rank: Forum user
|
Thanks Paul, I’ve just spoken to two health and safety professionals who also attended. Both agreed that it was the worst event they had ever attended. Totally disorganised and not value for money.
Following on from this, I won’t be wasting my hard earned cash at the London event.
|
|
|
|
Rank: Super forum user
|
I cannot afford to go. Even if I could I probably wouldn’t bother given the feedback I’ve had from others.
|
|
|
|
Rank: Forum user
|
|
|
|
|
You cannot post new topics in this forum.
You cannot reply to topics in this forum.
You cannot delete your posts in this forum.
You cannot edit your posts in this forum.
You cannot create polls in this forum.
You cannot vote in polls in this forum.