Posted By Paul Leadbetter Am I right in thinking that extinguishers within a fire compartment should conform either to the old, British Standard colour scheme or to the new, European scheme but that the schemes should not be mixed? When I said as much to a client, he challenged me to prove it and I have been unable to do so thus far! Thanks in anticipation Paul Leadbetter

Posted By John Bennett On a recent inspection carried out by the London Fire Brigade I was informed that the Brigade did not like to see the mixing of the old and new coloured extinguishers. However, it was acceptable for the extinguishers to be mixed on a floor level basis (i.e. 1st floor - new colour, 2nd floor - old colour etc.). Hope this helps.

Posted By Ken Taylor Whilst it's a good recommendation, it would be unreasonable for an employer to have to replace all existing fire extinguishers (or paint them) when a new replacement one is purchased and found to be red. If confusion cannot be avoided from the appearance of the extinguishers, suitable signs displayed adjacent and staff training should overcome the problem.

Posted By Jim Walker Regardless of what is legal or otherwise, the important thing is what is safe? Mixing is bound to be confusing. This (EEC originating) law is the most retro- grade action that has happened in fire safety in the past 20 years. Generally, I support most H&S legislation that has come out of the EEC as a step forward but we were badly let down on this one. My own solution is I've managed (as the result of a surplus) to retain the old colour code system. It only applies to the purchase of new extingishers and reurbishment of old ones is OK. Incidentally, if I could I would ban water extingishers. When do you ever get a fire that doesn't involve the potential of water coming into contact with electricity? Has anyone got views on this ?