i can't come up with a document but i would have thought one possible routes to look at following would be to come up with a list of headings for health and safety and when carrying out a tour list any issues under those headings then look at deducting the score under that one heading. Not sure if the skill set of the people on each site would make that greater difference of then qualifications or level of competence they should have for their job therefore understanding of health and safety they should be complying with or understanding. You might look at using headings like. Correct use of PPE Fire safety Welfare provisions Correct signage management procedure kept and being followed security of site Etc Etc.. I'm sure others and yourself could come up with more and possible relevant headings but as you then do a tour of the site and identify an issue you can then list it under the relevant heading than at the end of the tour you will quickly see if you have a particular issue in one or more areas. how you score the site percentage wise will depend on number of issues found and severity. You need to make sure that the more severe the issue harder the scoring will go against them. Phil

Thanks for the help.