Welcome Guest! The IOSH forums are a free resource to both members and non-members. Login or register to use them

Postings made by forum users are personal opinions. IOSH is not responsible for the content or accuracy of any of the information contained in forum postings. Please carefully consider any advice you receive.

Notification

Icon
Error

Options
Go to last post Go to first unread
Hall40727  
#1 Posted : 02 July 2010 22:02:35(UTC)
Rank: Forum user
Hall40727

hi,
i have been questioned on a method statment i have prepaired for the removal of non licences asbestos . ( removal of roof covering) as the site welfare facilitys are some distance away from the works i have suggested that the work area be fenced off and decontamination procedure carried out within this fenced off area. one of the last points in my decontamination procedure is to " wash before leaving work area" . i have been asked how the water, used for washing is going to be disposed of. i have looked through the acop and cant find my answer to this

can any one answer this question for me

thanks

David
Davey  
#2 Posted : 02 July 2010 23:32:22(UTC)
Rank: Forum user
Davey

Hello David
As this is none notifiable Asbestos work you may use the site washing facility as long as it is barried off and for your use alone the area can be cleaned down at the end of every working day using damp rags and then visually at the end of the job the area does not normally require an air clearance as for the waste water if the waste water is only contaminated with trace amounts of asbestos this may be discharged into the sewage system a very good referance document is HSG 210 asbestos essentials for none licesable work em8 personnel decontamination and em9 disposal of Asbestos waste also cat 2 training for none licesable work would be very good training if you have not recieved this already and as a minimum training legal requirment for this nature of work if you require any training please get in touch as i would be able to point you in the direction of a very good training provider hope this helps you out ......
Hall40727  
#3 Posted : 03 July 2010 09:30:52(UTC)
Rank: Forum user
Hall40727

hi davey,

thanks for that ,our lads have been trained in the removal of non licenced asbestos, but will have the details of the training you have as i have more lads to train up.

the client has an issue with the site welfare faclitys being used as they are about 100 meters away from the site of works. the intention was to decontaminate on the site of works as per the decontaimination procedure in the hse guide lines and as per their training. Obviously the rags etc would be baged and disposed of in the sealed skip etc, but the clents concern was with the disposal of the water that was used. i have looked through hsg 210 and the acop and could not see any thing on this. if i could find something in the hse guidance or acop stating how the water can safetly disposed of i can then put this to the client.

thanks
boblewis  
#4 Posted : 03 July 2010 18:21:00(UTC)
Rank: Super forum user
boblewis

This one worries me as I do find it hard to see the removal of a roof as low intensity and sporadic plus the other requirements of reg 3 CAR.

I think this one may well be licensable with a recalcitrant client trying to save money.

There are numerous decon units with water storage and you should be using one of these if the work is truly non-licensable - they are available to hire.

Bob
Davey  
#5 Posted : 03 July 2010 20:58:22(UTC)
Rank: Forum user
Davey

bob does have a very valid point as the removal of ac sheets is none notifiable only on a small scale so if the work is on a large scale you may be out of your depth and this may require the services of a HSE licesed contractor as if the ac sheets are on a large scale this work would not be deemed to be of short duration or sporadic if the work has been deemed to be small scale by meens of your risk assessment you will still be required to follow L143 the control of asbestos regulations also i would point you back to HSG 210 a14 Removing asbestos cement (AC) Sheets,Gutters etc and dismantling a SMALL AC structure and with regards to the disposal of waste water if you go to HSG 210 em 9 disposal of asbestos waste in the third paragraph it states that you can discharge waste water that may be contaminated with TRACES of asbestos waste into the sewage system. I do agree with bob though if this is not a small scale job then decons would be a better option and this should be put into the hands of a HSE licesed contractor so please reassess your scope of work David . The training provider i was refering to is Eddie Strong at Ferncroft Environmental a UKATA registered training provider
Ron Hunter  
#6 Posted : 03 July 2010 22:35:19(UTC)
Rank: Super forum user
Ron Hunter

On what basis would the careful removal of AC sheets ever be considered to be licensed work?
David, wearing disposable, hooded coveralls and careful bagging of these along with used tack-rags on every occassion you leave the work are should be adequate. Why do you want to use water (beyond the odd bucket or two)?
Hall40727  
#7 Posted : 03 July 2010 23:11:47(UTC)
Rank: Forum user
Hall40727

hi ron,
yes we are only talking a few buckets of water if that. the issue the clients advisor has raised is that after removing ppe in the correct manner that they want the operatives to wash hands etc on site of the works , rather than travel the 100meters to the welfare unit.the clients question was if we use any water on the site of works how will it be disposed of. the asbestos tests only gave a minimal trace of chrysotile. the only other alternative we have is to provide a mobile welfare unit at the site of the works, but then unless we provide welfare that is up to the standard for licensed work, where waste water gets fillterd ect the water from the standard welfare unit would be disharged as normal.
I beleve that as you pointed out that we are doing all we can concidering that its non licensed works.

thanks
Hall40727  
#8 Posted : 04 July 2010 00:29:12(UTC)
Rank: Forum user
Hall40727

forgot to say duration of the roof strip is approx 1 day (50m2)
and thanks all for your advice

David
boblewis  
#9 Posted : 04 July 2010 16:44:15(UTC)
Rank: Super forum user
boblewis

Ron

With respect can I point you to the requirements set out in regulation 3 for work to be non-licensable. All conditions have to be met and i feel this area is running close to the wind. Especially when I see that there is an ongoing programme of training persons for this work. Will such a trained group be exposed only to sporadic work ? - I think not, but I do know that a number of contractors are going down this route of training teams to handle all the AC sheet and similar. Against the intention of the regulations I think!! We need to look at this in relation to the work content of the operatives on a period basis not simply a single contract.

Bob
Ron Hunter  
#10 Posted : 05 July 2010 00:01:50(UTC)
Rank: Super forum user
Ron Hunter

Bob,
With equal respect, and happy to discuss the point:
The 4 conditions attached to Regulation 3(2)(c) are not collective (there is no "and" between (i), (ii),(iii) or (iv)). L143 p14 refers.
Removal of AC sheets, outside. Exposure can only really be sporadic and low intensity, irrespective of whether I do the task for an hour or for a fortnight. There are enough analytical measurements and commissioned reports to back that up.
I don't believe the letter or the spirit of the Regs is breached here.
Remember too that "sporadic" refers to fibre exposure, not the time taken on-task.
See also: http://www.hse.gov.uk/asbestos/regulations.htm
boblewis  
#11 Posted : 05 July 2010 17:27:03(UTC)
Rank: Super forum user
boblewis

Ron

I personally think the Low Intensity phrase is the one described by the fibre exposure and not sporadic as this word implies that operatives will only occassionally encounter ACM for work, this is not how it is being approached by some contractors who are are using the same people to regularly undertake this type of work.

I also recognise your statement concerning "and" as correct but find the wording messy unless there is a stronger intent to exclude work from licensing than I personally think was intended. In the case of this roof however I/and you are in the dark concerning condition and types of asbestos present.

Bob
Carter33769  
#12 Posted : 05 July 2010 18:13:11(UTC)
Rank: New forum user
Carter33769

Hi,

Just a quick question if the Main Contractor / Client is worried about one or two buckets of water contaminated with asbestos fibres from decontaminating, what are they saying about the wet strip/water suppression / mist spray you are applying whilst stripping the ACM roof sheets. Will you be setting out a bund system or have allowed to a shadow vacuum technique as you remove, how will the bag be disposed of as there is no full enclosure to open the vacuum, the questions are endless.
A simple answer to your first question is to bag the water in asbestos waste sacks, put some MMMF or sand into the bag then pour the water on top , the MMMF and sand will filter the water and adsorb, do not over fill the bags as this would become a manual handling issue. Seal the bags with cloth tape and dispose of with the roof sheets.
1. Roll out 1000 gauge polythene under the area to be removed.
2. Polythene the scissor lift
3. Create a small decontamination area containing 1 H Type Vacuum, 2 buckets of water, cloths, baby wipes ,a few asbestos waste bags and a few clean pairs of overalls
4. Wearing FFP3 masks as per your face fits, Type 5/6 Overalls, cleanable footwear, gloves, goggles, hi-viz(dispose of after), hard hats etc etc
5. Spray the underside of the exposed sheets with surfactant then spray the top to dampen any loose fibres.
6. Crop the sheets whole using bolt croppers
7. Lower between two operatives
8. Wrap in 1000 gauge polythene
9. Label with correct tipping information (stick a asbestos waste sack inside the polythene wrap)
10. Transport to skip
11. Repeat until roof sheets removed vacuuming roof joists etc as works progress.
12. Mop excess water up from polythene with rags and bag as contaminated waste
13. Roll polythene and bag as contaminated waste
14. Decontaminate with your Type H Vacuum, then wipe and wash mask, footwear etc etc
15. Dispose of mask and suit at washing station in bag also put cloths and baby wipes in waste bag
16. Change into new overalls
17. Dispose of water as above
18. Change into home clothes
19. Have tea in welfare facilities

Ron Hunter  
#13 Posted : 05 July 2010 23:23:43(UTC)
Rank: Super forum user
Ron Hunter

Bob, you and I might have to agree to disagree. I think we both agree the wording in the Regs is clumsy, however I think the statement at Reg 3(2) (a) is both inclusive and concise: "exposure of employees to asbestos is sporadic and of low intensity;".
Also my presumption is the roof being discussed is AC.
bod212  
#14 Posted : 06 July 2010 08:05:12(UTC)
Rank: Forum user
bod212

Carter33769 has it spot on. A simple, clear and concise way of doing the work. Removal of AC sheets is not a notifiable task. Careful removal from a roof is not a notifiable task. The job might be notified (and require a LARC) if something out of the norm was planned and the control limit was going to breached. It appears this job is not out of the norm.
Clairel  
#15 Posted : 06 July 2010 09:01:25(UTC)
Rank: Super forum user
Clairel

For non licenecsed asbestos removal guidance you should be using Asbestos Essentials, the HSE's official guidance on removal of all types of non-licenced work. Gives step by step guidance on removal, PPE/RPE, disposal etc

Can be downloaded for free from their website. That should give you all the advice you need.
Adrian Watson  
#16 Posted : 06 July 2010 09:19:41(UTC)
Rank: Forum user
Adrian Watson

Dear All,

Regulation 3(2) states:

Subject to paragraph (3), regulations 8 (licensing), 9 (notification of work with asbestos), 15(1)(arrangements to deal with accidents, incidents and emergencies), 18(1)(a)(asbestos areas) and 22 (health records and medical surveillance) shall not apply where—

(a)the exposure of employees to asbestos is sporadic and of low intensity;

(b)it is clear from the risk assessment that the exposure of any employee to asbestos will not exceed the control limit; and

(c)the work involves—

(i)short, non-continuous maintenance activities,
(ii)removal of materials in which the asbestos fibres are firmly linked in a matrix,
(iii)encapsulation or sealing of asbestos-containing materials which are in good condition, or
(iv)air monitoring and control, and the collection and analysis of samples to ascertain whether a specific material contains asbestos.

I agree with Ron, paragraphs 2 (a), (b) and (c) are conjunctive whilst the subparagraphs of paragraph(3) are in the alternative so the exposure to asbestos must be sporadic of low instensity and not exceed any control limit; and the work must be short, non-continuous maintenance activities or removal of bonded ACM or encapsulated of ACM in good condition or air sampling.

Therefore this work is not licensable as the work is not liable to exceed the control limit and exposures to asbestos is liable to be sporadic and low intensity and the work involves removal of materials in which the asbestos fibres are firmly linked in a matrix.

Regards Adrian
Hall40727  
#17 Posted : 06 July 2010 19:49:58(UTC)
Rank: Forum user
Hall40727

Carter33769 wrote:
Hi,

Just a quick question if the Main Contractor / Client is worried about one or two buckets of water contaminated with asbestos fibres from decontaminating, what are they saying about the wet strip/water suppression / mist spray you are applying whilst stripping the ACM roof sheets. Will you be setting out a bund system or have allowed to a shadow vacuum technique as you remove, how will the bag be disposed of as there is no full enclosure to open the vacuum, the questions are endless.
A simple answer to your first question is to bag the water in asbestos waste sacks, put some MMMF or sand into the bag then pour the water on top , the MMMF and sand will filter the water and adsorb, do not over fill the bags as this would become a manual handling issue. Seal the bags with cloth tape and dispose of with the roof sheets.
1. Roll out 1000 gauge polythene under the area to be removed.
2. Polythene the scissor lift
3. Create a small decontamination area containing 1 H Type Vacuum, 2 buckets of water, cloths, baby wipes ,a few asbestos waste bags and a few clean pairs of overalls
4. Wearing FFP3 masks as per your face fits, Type 5/6 Overalls, cleanable footwear, gloves, goggles, hi-viz(dispose of after), hard hats etc etc
5. Spray the underside of the exposed sheets with surfactant then spray the top to dampen any loose fibres.
6. Crop the sheets whole using bolt croppers
7. Lower between two operatives
8. Wrap in 1000 gauge polythene
9. Label with correct tipping information (stick a asbestos waste sack inside the polythene wrap)
10. Transport to skip
11. Repeat until roof sheets removed vacuuming roof joists etc as works progress.
12. Mop excess water up from polythene with rags and bag as contaminated waste
13. Roll polythene and bag as contaminated waste
14. Decontaminate with your Type H Vacuum, then wipe and wash mask, footwear etc etc
15. Dispose of mask and suit at washing station in bag also put cloths and baby wipes in waste bag
16. Change into new overalls
17. Dispose of water as above
18. Change into home clothes
19. Have tea in welfare facilities


hi carter,
the method for removal you have stated was the method of removal that we proposed, in our method statment , apart from the disposal of the water. We have contacted the environment agency and they have no issue with a few buckets of water being discharged into the drainage sysyem, although we will now use the method you have come up with.

thank you.
David
Users browsing this topic
Guest (2)
You cannot post new topics in this forum.
You cannot reply to topics in this forum.
You cannot delete your posts in this forum.
You cannot edit your posts in this forum.
You cannot create polls in this forum.
You cannot vote in polls in this forum.