Welcome Guest! The IOSH forums are a free resource to both members and non-members. Login or register to use them

Postings made by forum users are personal opinions. IOSH is not responsible for the content or accuracy of any of the information contained in forum postings. Please carefully consider any advice you receive.

Notification

Icon
Error

Options
Go to last post Go to first unread
Clairel  
#1 Posted : 25 November 2010 19:32:08(UTC)
Rank: Super forum user
Clairel

Seen a lot of posts recently from people trying to get into the profession and not having any joy with their first position and questioning what they can do about it.

Well, I'm post grad qualified in H&S, over 10 years experience and CMIOSH and I can barely get an interview. Haven't been able to get self employed stuff off the ground (don't think I'm suited to selling myself in all honesty) and there are no jobs and those there are I don't even get an interview for. I'm baffled and also shell shocked by the current work situation.

The area of the country I live in doesn't help as there is virtually nothing doing up here but I cannot (and will not) move, my life is here. Some things are more important. But also employers seem to want more than just a H&S bod nowadays they want lots of bolt-ons too (FM, environment, quality) or up here it seems to be the specialisms like COMAH, off-shore or nuclear. I have none of those.

So this is as bad as it gets, I am now looking for opportunites outside of health and safety. To start again in another job or career. I don't know where or what but it feels like I'm banging my head against a brick wall trying to get another H&S job and I need to start thinking about bringing in some pennies again, even at a much lesser rate than I'm used to.

So, unless another job comes winging its way in my direction this may be the end of my time on this forum. Just thought I'd let you all know. As I've been around a while, even in forums past.

Heads up on opportunities in any arena welcome!

Rick Warner  
#2 Posted : 25 November 2010 19:42:18(UTC)
Rank: Forum user
Rick Warner

I truely feel for you mate, what a waste if the unmentionable does happen. Due to your post, i appear to be having a change of heart, i am merely Tech IOSH and am the named Safety Advisor for a Demolition company, i have been in the trade for almost 30 years now and have worked my way through the ranks.

It is immensly busy down South mate and of late, i have been getting very depressed as a result of my additional work load, i work far too many hours and also at home at the weekend, (all overtime at no additional pay) and i have personally been of the opinnion that i need to look elsewhere for employment. But by reading posts such as yours, well i feel that i should think myself lucky and get on with it.

Hope things change for the better for you soon!
bleve  
#3 Posted : 25 November 2010 23:21:33(UTC)
Rank: Super forum user
bleve

Claire
Sorry to hear that.

May be a case of dumbing down your cv or try and source training to enable access to Comah or other work i.e FRA or consider BOHS modules and try to specialise.

Comah, fire safety or DSEAR is not rocket science and can be understood by anyone in a short duration.

Key is to find that niche.

If you have evidence of lesser safety qualification, use that in order to get foot in the door and earn a few bob until things improve, from experience multiple (MSc) sometimes higher qualifications can and are a hinderence in the job market.

bleve  
#4 Posted : 25 November 2010 23:24:04(UTC)
Rank: Super forum user
bleve

Also and just a thought have you criticaly reviewed your CV? Maybe this has had an impact on selection for interview?

Clairel  
#5 Posted : 26 November 2010 07:52:20(UTC)
Rank: Super forum user
Clairel

All the agencies seem to think my CV's good.

The trouble with getting further quals is:

a) Which ones? For example, if I get further fire quals then I may find lots of jobs in asbestos coming up instead etc etc. Quals are expensive and time consmuing and if you get one lot then there's no guarantee that jobs with thsoe bolt ons will come along. It could be an expensive mistake when I have no money coming in in the first place.

b) Quals aren't enough. With so few jobs and so many candidates to choose from they want the specialisms plus experience in those specialisms. Which puts me back in the same position as new people coming into the profession.

I'm very expereinced in H&S but that just doesn't seem to be enough at the moment.

So I'll keep my eyes open but my attention is now turned to other opportunities. Sad maybe, but I can't sit around waiting for the job market to change. There aren't even any local jobs I can apply for at the moment in H&S. It's that bad.
SP900308  
#6 Posted : 26 November 2010 08:18:31(UTC)
Rank: Super forum user
SP900308

Clairel,

A loss to the industry and a reflection of the termoil our country is in right now. Look at previous SHP job pages (2007) and you'll se page after page of jobs with salaries possibly higher than those of late. I know going back a while you suggested changing your career focus, maybe it was a difficult spot you were going through, maybe your soul really is in H&S? With a decade 'time served', any change is a daunting prospect!

I understand you were working for a consultancy recently, surely you have a large portfolio of Clients', many of which were returning their business to you specifically?!

Have you got any mates that are better placed to market you as freelance? Maybe agencies? Some consultancies are still using freelance support I understand!
Have you got any Project Management experience / Quals?
Could you use construction / design experience to tap into CDMC work?

I wish you all the best, hopefully we'll still get the benefit of your honest opinions and stimulative debates in the future.

Simon
m  
#7 Posted : 26 November 2010 08:34:21(UTC)
Rank: Super forum user
m

Hi Clairel, if you are not skilled at selling yourself can you get some else to do that for you? It will be a cost but there are people that will hit a phone directory and cold call to get you through the door as a consultant; it'll be over to you then. May be see if the local newspaper knows someone who will do the cold calling for you. Don't take your skills and experience away -at the very least stay in touch via the forums

Good Luck!

m
Clairel  
#8 Posted : 26 November 2010 09:53:25(UTC)
Rank: Super forum user
Clairel

Hi Simon, yes I was contemplating getting out of this troubled profession a while ago but having weighed up my options I realised I was better off staying put. How ironic that I now can't get work in H&S!!!

Consultancies have an exclusion on contacting any of their clients for 12 months after leaving employment and so I wasn't able to. I could now but all the clients are bound into a contract with my ex-employer (most of them for 3 years) and times are tough. I got a bit of ad hoc work but that has dried up. I couldn't compete with the H&S / Personnel service that my ex-employer and many consultancies provide.

I have tried getting into CDM Roles, Mg't roles etc. I've even had interviews I know I could do the job but when you're up against others with more experience in those specific fields of work my expereince in general H&S takes second place. I'm always told that I interviewed well, nothing wrong, could do the job but someone else had exactly the right experience they were looking for.

M - I'm not keen on getting clients by cold calling, it's a not a practice I'm a fan of, whether I do it myself or get someone else to do it for me.

Thanks for all the responses. I'll keep looking but I have to cut my losses at some point and start again. Think I may have found a little franchise business I could do from home with minimal start up costs. Who knows, if I leave H&S maybe I'll revert back to being a less grumpy individual and more of a laugh like I used to be 10 years ago!!
Steve e ashton  
#9 Posted : 26 November 2010 10:29:46(UTC)
Rank: Super forum user
Steve e ashton

Claire:

Is it possible you may be able to re-state what you currently see as negatives into positives? When applying for my current role, and previously when winning two major consultancy projects, the absence of inductry specific indoctrination and blinkers was used a unique selling point!

It sometimes takes someone from outside to spot the obvious faults that those within the industry have lived with for years. And in my experience the 'industry bar' can usually only be raised by someone from outside the industry who doesn't know 'this is the way its always been done' and isn't afraid to ask the daft questions like 'why?'.

With your breadth of experience, and your proven ability to assimilate and interpret new requirements - you could be just the asset the next megabucks recruiter is looking for. So don't give up completely.

But all the best with whatever the future brings.

Steve....
TSC  
#10 Posted : 26 November 2010 11:08:37(UTC)
Rank: Forum user
TSC

My reommendation is to keep trying. Economic climate is very poor and Health and Safety especially has took a battering.

I fI was to look at bolt on training I think I would aim at Management Systems and the assessment standards i.e. 18001, 9001 and 14001 or the PAS 99. Consider linking with awarding bodies of certification to offer your service and theirs additionally at discount.

I was lucky enough to be offered a position before the end of my redundancy notice although does not pay well. In addition I have been there with all the interviews and told I could do the job and interviewed well etc.

Had the recruitment agencies sales patter of we should get you a position, your quals etc are great and experience is what clients require.

My own consultancy in Safety has slowed to a halt but I have re-invented it and expanded with a Sister company in event management and safety.

Keep your chin up keep chipping away and although you do not like cold calling people (I hate it!) it does work. When cold calling be honest and admit pretty quickly why you are on the phone.

Look for any companies locally that may have had increased work orders and in house teams can't cope. I may be going in as a consutlant for training to my last employer of 5 years that made me redundant as they do not have the resources and I understand their business.

Best of luck

Regards

TSC
alexmccreadie13  
#11 Posted : 26 November 2010 11:34:22(UTC)
Rank: Super forum user
alexmccreadie13

Clairel

You might want to look at NVQ Assessor there is more and more requirement for assessors now.

The CPCS and CSCS cards are in some cases requiring NVQ for specific categories I am sure you could pass the required course (old A1)and keep yourself going until times are better.

Good Luck

Captain Safety  
#12 Posted : 26 November 2010 11:58:26(UTC)
Rank: Forum user
Captain Safety

Clairel I fully understand how you feel, how fruastrated you are and the pressure & support you must be going through from family and friends, as the end of the day you have to put bread on the table. I was made redundant last Christmas (great present) as H&S Manager and was out of work for 6 months.
Going to interviews and infact actual turning down a lower paid job as H&S Manager not because of the money but morales and what they wanted me to put my name to, the director said when can start and I said you will have to look else where as just 1 instance was to put my name to RAMS for skywalking along a roof.
I many times contemplated leaving H&S as I have many of the nuts and bolts employers are looking for Contract Management,Surveying,Supervising etc and still not being successful, but I was told by many agencies and friends remove some of your qualifications and experiences to get your foot in the door but I refused as I would not delete whole sections of my Career to suit some employers.
I stuck with it and now contract, on my second contract again no certainties from week to week but pennies come in although I do commute 150 miles round trip a day.


The only advise I can give mate is dont give in keep your head up and cliche it might be but "The cream always comes to the top"
bob youel  
#13 Posted : 26 November 2010 15:35:53(UTC)
Rank: Super forum user
bob youel

Firstly before people laugh this is a genuine comment as I hate to see good people in trouble - I have gone through at least 3 recessions so I know what its all about

try getting yourself into the funeral/undertakers game as it is the one and only recession proof industry -believe me - From there you can have £ coming in and can weather the recession from that area - you might even pick up work as they too need a Reg 7 advice person and its an interesting area!

Marketing/selling yourself is the answer and if you are not physically visiting a good few companies per day then you are not doing enough

As for nuclear /offshore etc the truth is that 80% of all areas are basically the same; I know as I have worked in both of them and many others so keep pushing [I mean pushing] as your skills are transferable

Get a cleaners job via an agency that works in a Nuc power station / offshore base etc and get in with the manager -it CAN be done
best of luck
Clairel  
#14 Posted : 26 November 2010 16:47:47(UTC)
Rank: Super forum user
Clairel

Bob,

Oddly I do have quite a lot of experience of giving H&S advice to undertakers. Nicer bunch of people you couldn't wish to meet. And yes there are plently of H&S issues to deal with.

The trouble is I am fairly confident in my transferable skills but with so many people going for one job it's difficult to get employers to take that chance when they don't have to take the chance on someone else.

Equally I did admit that I am not good at selling myself as a self employed consultant and that's why it hasn't worked for me. Must be a confidence problem (honestly!!!).. Oddly I can sell a product or service but not myself.

Thanks for all the kind words everyone.
ITER  
#15 Posted : 26 November 2010 17:29:14(UTC)
Rank: Forum user
ITER

Clairel

I hope we don't loose you down to earth pragmatic and down to earth approach to h&s, trying to reign in some of the h&s zealots. I have agreed with your arguments an points of view on many occasions - not always replying though.

As someone has said, finding a niche area is the way to go.

If you can argue any human factors experience the nuclear sector is screaming out for HF people - although I upset people by considering HF not to be a specialist subject [with the exception of occupational psychology] - its normal safety with a different change of emphasis.

I understand your from the Yorkshire area - the same as me, and understand your desire not to move/relocate - why not try the nuclear or oil/gas sector in a contract role, for a short period of working away it could end up being pretty well paid.

There are jobs out there - I have applied for 5 jobs in the last month, all nuclear/oil/gas and have generated 4 interviews. However, it does help if you also have an engineering/science degree as well.

DSEAR/COMAH, writing safety cases isn't difficult.

Victor Meldrew  
#16 Posted : 27 November 2010 18:35:46(UTC)
Rank: Guest
Guest

So sorry to hear your news Clairel, I've really appreciated your input and views on this forum and you will no doubt also be a sad loss to the industry if you decide to leave. Only one thing I can suggest, have you tried any local industrial estate(s) to see if any small businesses want you to be their H&S person and charge them on a lower than average yearly retainer?.......it worked for me when I started and as I developed the business I now have someone working for me to look after that side of things. Other than that I cannot add to anything already provided above. All the best in your endeavours.
Robson22518  
#17 Posted : 29 November 2010 15:23:29(UTC)
Rank: Forum user
Robson22518

Just on this post, Clair, i am also looking for emplyment, although the NVQ assessor training which was pointed out may be a good idea
Any idea how to go about that and what training, test is required to achieve this ?
Keep trying Clair hopefully something will come up for you ( and me too )
redken  
#18 Posted : 30 November 2010 11:19:19(UTC)
Rank: Super forum user
redken

December SHP, Jobs: two councils- three jobs, one university-two jobs, one private company- one job. Three agencies with allegedly 20 jobs between them.

The rest of the magazine is pretty thin as well with articles stretching small points e.g. Downstream Reach.
alexmccreadie13  
#19 Posted : 30 November 2010 15:54:51(UTC)
Rank: Super forum user
alexmccreadie13

Robbo

Google A1 NVQ Assessors Training and you should find someone close to you.

I have sourced 1 in Warminster Wiltshire but I think that is to far for you. Quoting between £500-£600 for the full award.

Good Luck

Alex

RayRapp  
#20 Posted : 01 December 2010 09:13:16(UTC)
Rank: Super forum user
RayRapp

ClaireL

It is a very difficult climate at present for jobs even for those like me working in the SE/London area with good qualifications and experience. I have applied for a few jobs recently but no joy, at best an interview. Employers can be so choosy due to many applicants I presume. I am currently freelancing via a consultancy and it is not necessarily by choice. Luckily I can survive with a modest income for the time being, but I appreciate that for others it is a precarious situation. Outside of h&s I suspect it is just as difficult with low pay being the result. Good luck and best wishes.
Clairel  
#21 Posted : 01 December 2010 09:37:42(UTC)
Rank: Super forum user
Clairel

Ray - Yes I too can survive on no income if necessary as my husband in the main breadwinner and we have kept our living expenses based on just his income (in case of circumstances like this!!). But can't keep this up indefinately and certainly we're on a very restricted lifetyle. Just frustrates me having to do this at my time in life and makes me quite useless as I like to earn my keep. Maybe I'll try contacting some consultancies for freelance work. Most don't seem to do that anymore though.

Thanks for all the responses everyone. All the kind words and suggestions really are appreciated as it becomes very demoralising day after day and I am certainly struggling to keep myself from getting depressed about the situation. Thank goodness I love the free activity of hill running as right now it's keeping me sane!!
SP900308  
#22 Posted : 01 December 2010 10:31:06(UTC)
Rank: Super forum user
SP900308

Clairel,

If you see any Haggis, bag a few - could be worth a few quid this time of year ;)

All the best

Simon
Fletcher  
#23 Posted : 02 December 2010 16:30:27(UTC)
Rank: Super forum user
Fletcher

Afternoon All,

I am in a similar position to Claire and would thank all posters for their comments which have given me ideas.

Claire,

Stick in there girl,
As my old coach used to say
"Winners never quit and quitters never win"

My wife always tells me that Yorkshire lasses are by nature fighters then she adds that it is because they have to put up with Yorkshiremen.

Good Luck and I hope things work out for you

Take Care

bob youel  
#24 Posted : 13 December 2010 13:16:46(UTC)
Rank: Super forum user
bob youel

Try schools, clubs and similar as they do have issues and you may be able to provide a sensible 'price' for short periods as you are using common sense and living mainly on your partners income

The 1 big hurdle to get over is the marketing and selling of yourself and only U can do that - try marketing etc a little bit at a time

Trust: Another thing to note is that unfortunately trust is lacking so be wary and make sure your agreements re pay etc are written down; even in a short friendly email
ChrissyH  
#25 Posted : 14 December 2010 10:27:19(UTC)
Rank: New forum user
ChrissyH

Hi Guys, Am new to this forum and quite interested in all the comments. I had to 're-invent' myself and used the networking circles to do it. Breakfast clubs like BNI etc allow you to visit a couple of times without paying memberships. I joined in the end and found a lot of work that way. It's not who is around the table as much as who their client list is and a personal recommendation from a member can go a long way. It's worth a try.
I have found though that things have slowed down - mainly due to Lord Youngs report and all that surrounds it. People have the notion that H & S is being scrapped for some reason and I had a hard job convincing people it was not. I'm ticking along - companies don't want to employ H & S officers and advisers full time they want to pay someone to do a job and then go away so the freelance market could be a way forward offering your services like that.
Hope you find something soon
decimomal  
#26 Posted : 14 December 2010 15:02:46(UTC)
Rank: Super forum user
decimomal

Hello Claire,it looks as though you are doing all the righr things.
You say that the agencies think your CV is good. Are they actually working hard on your behalf in securing you a position ? Have you considered short term contract work?

Best of luck in your endevours.
Clairel  
#27 Posted : 14 December 2010 17:59:03(UTC)
Rank: Super forum user
Clairel

Did a short term contract that finished mid November. Horrendous commuting of 126 miles day, absolutely exhausted me and so was quite glad when it ended, although missed the regular income!!
rockybalboa  
#28 Posted : 10 January 2011 23:26:02(UTC)
Rank: Forum user
rockybalboa

Clairel wrote:
Seen a lot of posts recently from people trying to get into the profession and not having any joy with their first position and questioning what they can do about it.

Well, I'm post grad qualified in H&S, over 10 years experience and CMIOSH and I can barely get an interview. Haven't been able to get self employed stuff off the ground (don't think I'm suited to selling myself in all honesty) and there are no jobs and those there are I don't even get an interview for. I'm baffled and also shell shocked by the current work situation.

The area of the country I live in doesn't help as there is virtually nothing doing up here but I cannot (and will not) move, my life is here. Some things are more important. But also employers seem to want more than just a H&S bod nowadays they want lots of bolt-ons too (FM, environment, quality) or up here it seems to be the specialisms like COMAH, off-shore or nuclear. I have none of those.

So this is as bad as it gets, I am now looking for opportunites outside of health and safety. To start again in another job or career. I don't know where or what but it feels like I'm banging my head against a brick wall trying to get another H&S job and I need to start thinking about bringing in some pennies again, even at a much lesser rate than I'm used to.

So, unless another job comes winging its way in my direction this may be the end of my time on this forum. Just thought I'd let you all know. As I've been around a while, even in forums past.

Heads up on opportunities in any arena welcome!



Iain Duncan Smith said it best, "get on your bike". It may not be what you want to hear but whats the point of reversing 10 years of a career for lower pay just to stay in the same area where "there is virtually nothing doing up here".

That sounds a bit bonkers to me.
Hally  
#29 Posted : 11 January 2011 11:17:15(UTC)
Rank: Super forum user
Hally

Norman Tebbitt also said it. Not sure what he'd have said if everyone from north of Birmingham (as well as Wales, Sctoland and NI) had all turned up in London for work...
sean  
#30 Posted : 11 January 2011 11:48:42(UTC)
Rank: Guest
Guest

Hally wrote:
Norman Tebbitt also said it. Not sure what he'd have said if everyone from north of Birmingham (as well as Wales, Sctoland and NI) had all turned up in London for work...


Hally, they did!!!!!
gotogmca  
#31 Posted : 11 January 2011 13:37:02(UTC)
Rank: Forum user
gotogmca

Good luck to all of you out there. I had a similar experience 7 years ago when I was made redundant from the chemical industry and I changed my career to health and safety from laboratory management and all I had was my NEBOSH certificate plus experience in the chemical industry. Took me nearly 8 months to find someone who would take me on with so little direct 'experience' as a health and safety professional. However, still have the job 6 years later but the daily commute of 152 miles does get me down at times! It can be done, but it is difficult. I would like to get a job closer to home but again it is a tough market out there at present.
Clairel  
#32 Posted : 11 January 2011 14:58:29(UTC)
Rank: Super forum user
Clairel

Hello!! Just popped on to the IOSH site the last few days to update my contact details and update my CPD, while I remember (....and just in case!!).

Suprised to see this thread resurrected.

Speirsy, I think you have a bit of a cheek actually by telling me that I should up sticks and move and for me not to is bonkers. Even if I wanted to, and I don't at this moment in time, it's actually not possible - or perhaps you think I should dump my daughter out of her home, as she is living at home while she is at Uni??

I work to live and not the other way round and so why should I give up where I live - my friends, family, recreational activities (I do a lot of outdoor sports) - just to get a job? Why destroy my current lifestyle just to get a job, that makes no sense to me? I have a different perspective than that on life. It's called quality of life, which I determine in happiness not the size of my bank account. What's the point in having money if I'm so unhappy with the rest of my life??

Yep I'm broke at the moment but actually at my least stressed, and therefore happiest, for a long time. About to start my new businesses (unrelated to H&S) and have a few irons in the fire for some other (H&S related) work on the side to keep me going until then. I donlt know what the future holds, whether it be in H&S or not. I'm just living for today and taking the opportunities that arise today. Instead of sitting brooding at all the closed doors in my face I decided to do something different. Does that make me bonkers?????????

Ah well. That's enough of that. I won't be back on for a while again as I have no need at the moment (I'm all updated!).

Hope everyone is well and good luck for 2011!!! :-)
Paul H11  
#33 Posted : 11 January 2011 17:55:42(UTC)
Rank: Forum user
Paul H11

Dear Clairel,

As an Employer searching this site for potential candidates, I must be honest and say that I was immediately put off by the statement that you would not be willing to move, not so much the statement but more the attitude. I want people that are willing to give up some things to achieve not someone who doesn't want to be inconvenienced by it all.
I wish you good fortune and hope you get what you want.
brian02  
#34 Posted : 13 January 2011 11:47:11(UTC)
Rank: Forum user
brian02

Hi Cairel,
I live in Manchester area,just passed Diploma and over 20 years experience in roofing and your right theres nothing in safety work,trying my own website at the moment but I think I am wasting my time.
Hope you get some luck.
Brian
Users browsing this topic
Guest (7)
You cannot post new topics in this forum.
You cannot reply to topics in this forum.
You cannot delete your posts in this forum.
You cannot edit your posts in this forum.
You cannot create polls in this forum.
You cannot vote in polls in this forum.