Ron, I could not agree more, and as my final word, I would therefore refer you to the following:
The 2nd Edition of the Guide to application of the Machinery Directive 2006/42/EC was endorsed by the EU Machinery Committee on 2 June 2010.
http://ec.europa.eu/ente...rs/mechanical/machinery/In particular:
Page 60: § 80 A person manufacturing machinery for his own use
A person who manufactures machinery for his own use is considered as a
Manufacturer and must fulfil all the obligations set out in Article 5. In that case, the machinery is not placed on the market, since it is not made available by the manufacturer to another person but used by the manufacturer himself. However, such machinery must comply with the Machinery Directive before it is put into service – see §86: comments on Article 2 (k).
Page 63: § 86 the definition of ‘putting into service’
The Machinery Directive applies to machinery when it is placed on the market and/or put into service.
In the case of machinery manufactured by a person for his own use (that is not placed on the market), the Machinery Directive applies when the machinery or assembly of machinery is first put into service. In other words, such machinery must comply with ALL the provisions of the Directive before it is first used for its intended purpose in the EU.
Note the stipulation of compliance with ALL the provisions.
Finally, see requirements of Article 5:
Article 5
Placing on the market and putting into service
1. Before placing machinery on the market and/or putting it into service, the
manufacturer or his authorised representative shall:
(a) ensure that it satisfies the relevant essential health and safety requirements set out in Annex I;
(b) ensure that the technical file referred to in Annex VII, part A is available;
(c) provide, in particular, the necessary information, such as instructions;
(d) carry out the appropriate procedures for assessing conformity in accordance with Article 12;
(e) draw up the EC declaration of conformity in accordance with Annex II, part 1, Section A and ensure that it accompanies the machinery;
(f) affix the CE marking in accordance with Article 16.
Now tell me that you disagree with the specific matter of interpretation given by the same people who issued the Machinery Directives.