Welcome Guest! The IOSH forums are a free resource to both members and non-members. Login or register to use them

Postings made by forum users are personal opinions. IOSH is not responsible for the content or accuracy of any of the information contained in forum postings. Please carefully consider any advice you receive.

Notification

Icon
Error

Options
Go to last post Go to first unread
kevinmuir  
#1 Posted : 31 July 2012 17:12:40(UTC)
Rank: Forum user
kevinmuir

I'm certain this question has been asked but have struggled to find a definitive answer.

Q. A haulage contractor delivers and collects heavy construction plant - excavators, rollers, dumpers, forklifts, MEWPS etc to a construction site. Problem: Site manager requests a copy of his CPCS card to operate the plant, he doesn't have one as it is wholly impractical to expect a lorry driver to hold a CPCS accredited card for every potential item of plant to be transported.
My understanding is this has always been a 'grey area'. Driver is ultimately responsible for securing load when transported but timing of deliveries often means a trained plant operator is not always available on site.
Secondly, at no time during the CPCS training plan do they instruct how to load and unload plant on/off trailers.
Yes, we need to be able to demonstrate competence, yes this could be classed a high risk operation with a chance the load slides off the ramps etc but, how, if no-one is accredited to teach this operation do we comply.
Anyone want to have a realistic bash at this????
Jake  
#2 Posted : 01 August 2012 08:20:46(UTC)
Rank: Super forum user
Jake

This is not my area, but since there hasn't been another reply I'll add some thoughts.

I see how you are frustrated, the training for each item of equipment is quite detailed and will cover all operational aspects of the equipment, but hauliers only need to know how to operate the motive and emergency controls to drive on / off the HGV.

Clearly there is a risk both to the businesses and to the health and safety of the employee. Without training how can you expect the haulier to know how to operate the machine (I certainly couldn't just jump into a forklift and drive it on / off a HGV trailer!!) if they haven’t been given any training? On the flip-side, should anything happen the business will be wide open to criticism / enforcement action. I would not be satisfied with the current level of business risk, IMO.

Can an agreement be arranged with the sites that a trained site operative is available to conduct the task? (unless you're doing night shifts I'm sure this can be worked round, the only issue being the site manager may be reluctant to allow their operative onto your vehicle), certainly our company policy is that any deliveries are the responsibility of the supplier / haulier until unloaded into our warehouses.

In all honesty I think you'll have to bite the bullet and get the hauliers trained. You state that the training doesn't cover the loading / unloading from trailers, well of course it wouldn't! But the training will cover all the safety controls, how to actually move the damn thing, how to move the machine correctly and in a controlled manner and will no doubt be practical so the haulier can get to grips with what it feels like to operate the machine.
Lawlee45239  
#3 Posted : 01 August 2012 11:01:30(UTC)
Rank: Super forum user
Lawlee45239

kevinmuir wrote:
I'm certain this question has been asked but have struggled to find a definitive answer.

Q. A haulage contractor delivers and collects heavy construction plant - excavators, rollers, dumpers, forklifts, MEWPS etc to a construction site. Problem: Site manager requests a copy of his CPCS card to operate the plant, he doesn't have one as it is wholly impractical to expect a lorry driver to hold a CPCS accredited card for every potential item of plant to be transported.
My understanding is this has always been a 'grey area'. Driver is ultimately responsible for securing load when transported but timing of deliveries often means a trained plant operator is not always available on site.
Secondly, at no time during the CPCS training plan do they instruct how to load and unload plant on/off trailers.
Yes, we need to be able to demonstrate competence, yes this could be classed a high risk operation with a chance the load slides off the ramps etc but, how, if no-one is accredited to teach this operation do we comply.
Anyone want to have a realistic bash at this????



This also appies to fitters who attend site to carry out servicing/ repairs on plant, none of which have CPCS cards to operate such.

Are the items of plant on 'hire' to your company?? If so then perhaps contact the hire company and see where you all stand and insurances are concerned.
kevinmuir  
#4 Posted : 01 August 2012 11:14:06(UTC)
Rank: Forum user
kevinmuir

We are actually the plant hire company and haulage contractor, so good point made as we also have the fitters carrying out repairs.

We are in the process of getting all fitters and lorry dirvers to hold atleast the basis CSCS card as sites wont let these guys on without one. Not easy as the CSCS is primarily geared towards construction obviously but fitters and drivers are more from a transport and automotive industry.

IMHO, I think the way to go is to devise a training plan to cover familiarisation on basic controls only on each item of plant and issue and in-house certification. Hopefully, this will 'pacify' the over eager site managers.

Lawlee45239  
#5 Posted : 01 August 2012 11:24:55(UTC)
Rank: Super forum user
Lawlee45239

kevinmuir wrote:
We are actually the plant hire company and haulage contractor, so good point made as we also have the fitters carrying out repairs.

We are in the process of getting all fitters and lorry dirvers to hold atleast the basis CSCS card as sites wont let these guys on without one. Not easy as the CSCS is primarily geared towards construction obviously but fitters and drivers are more from a transport and automotive industry.

IMHO, I think the way to go is to devise a training plan to cover familiarisation on basic controls only on each item of plant and issue and in-house certification. Hopefully, this will 'pacify' the over eager site managers.



It is good to see that the Site Managers are getting stuck in and thinking of these issues though.

Ant Elsmore  
#6 Posted : 01 August 2012 15:43:14(UTC)
Rank: Forum user
Ant Elsmore

Hi Kevin,

CPCS categories A49 & A50 are Loader/ Securer competencies for Non-STGO & STGO Low Loader plant deliveries.

Hope this helps.
Ant
Mudmuppet  
#7 Posted : 02 August 2012 16:03:51(UTC)
Rank: Forum user
Mudmuppet

All too often companies are subscribed to the UKCG which demands the site manager to ask these questions, CPCS is not the only competency to be relied on.
It is a grey area and would suggest that training providers look into this and tailor training to the specific needs of the haulage contractors.
CPCS categories A49 and A50 are all about securing the loads not the physical operation of the many differing plant types, but for my company under UKCG rules would expect this competency.
kevinmuir  
#8 Posted : 02 August 2012 16:14:07(UTC)
Rank: Forum user
kevinmuir

Since my original post, have spoken with a couple of training providers about this.

Apparently CPCS have very recently tried to come up with a solution which involves the driver/fitter sitting both the theory and practical test on each plant but on a far simpler criteria.

Another alternative offered, was the NPORS route which can gear the training/assessment towards specific requirements of the trainee.

NPORS sound more practical (as it usually tends to be) but will probably be forced into following the new CPCS, but this form still to be confirmed. I'm certain though that there still wont be a section specific to physically loading the plant.

mudmuppet :
had already looked at the a49 & a50 categories but as you state this is only for securing the loads as it identified 2 specific roles in the criteria the securer/loader and the operator.
Julian Powell  
#9 Posted : 02 February 2015 12:10:37(UTC)
Rank: Forum user
Julian Powell

Hi Kevin,

I know this is an old post, but I have recently had similar questions to the ones you asked.

Specifically, who should be loading and unloading machines from a low loader - the lorry driver or drivers on site? Who is responsible for ensuring the load is secured properly in the first instance - not just the driver checking the load is secured before joining the public highway.

What conclusion did you come to in the end?

Cheers

Julian Powell
fscott  
#10 Posted : 02 February 2015 14:10:22(UTC)
Rank: Forum user
fscott

In previous employment where I worked in quarrying industry we had a similar issue with our fitters. We directly employed qualified CPCS Instructors and using the CPCS Theory Test Question and Practical Test Standards (both of which are publicly available on CPCS website) we devised an in-house training programme/competence check for our fitters to allow them to operate plant providing them with our own in-house certificates of competence. Competence checks were re-done every 3 years on immediately in the event of an incident. Our guys only operated on our own sites so we didn't have the issues of 'that's not acceptable'. The training/competence checks covered pre-start checks, start up procedures, travelling/manoeuvring and shut down procedures.
Plant trainer  
#11 Posted : 04 February 2015 14:01:28(UTC)
Rank: Forum user
Plant trainer

The world has moved on a little bit in the quarries, we now have access through the MPQC card scheme for an auxhillary card specifically for fitters which covers the basics of pre use/start up and moving the vehicle for maintenance. There is also a VQ qualification for low loader operators which the driver can gain endorsements for plant types, so they do a basic loading and unloading qualification to cvoer securing of loads etc, then they can take additional assessments for dumpers, excavators shovels etc to cover basic start up and manouvreing for unloading and drop off of plant.
fscott  
#12 Posted : 04 February 2015 16:36:48(UTC)
Rank: Forum user
fscott

Plant trainer wrote:
The world has moved on a little bit in the quarries, we now have access through the MPQC card scheme for an auxhillary card specifically for fitters which covers the basics of pre use/start up and moving the vehicle for maintenance. There is also a VQ qualification for low loader operators which the driver can gain endorsements for plant types, so they do a basic loading and unloading qualification to cvoer securing of loads etc, then they can take additional assessments for dumpers, excavators shovels etc to cover basic start up and manouvreing for unloading and drop off of plant.


Good to know Plant Trainer. I've been out the industry for about four years now and MPQC was just coming into play around the time I left with a lot of unknown questions.
Users browsing this topic
Guest
You cannot post new topics in this forum.
You cannot reply to topics in this forum.
You cannot delete your posts in this forum.
You cannot edit your posts in this forum.
You cannot create polls in this forum.
You cannot vote in polls in this forum.