Rank: Forum user
|
Hi all, I'm looking for feedback / comments from other forum members on the current recruitment trend in our industry, specifically in the UK. All comments will be welcome either on here or via PM.
Some time ago we advertised a couple of vacancies for H&S consultancy / training roles in all the usual places including SHP, and were surprised by the lack of applications for an employed role, compared with the number who were looking for 'associate' work. The advertised roles were not unusual, the package offered was reasonable, and our location is not remote. If possible I would like comments from any other members who have been recruiting recently regarding the ratio of applications received, especially if the roles you were advertising were similar.
The reason for asking for your comments is purely to help with a decision regarding the status of my workers going forward, my company has a bank of associates that we do call on occasionally, but in the main we use employed individuals in these roles, in fact we consider one of our 'selling' points is that we use mainly employed consultants / tutors. This thought process may well have to change if my recent findings are backed up by your comments.
Many thanks in advance, Mike
|
|
|
|
Rank: Super forum user
|
Mixed for me - I recently recruited a regional safety manager, good salary, car, pension and bonus. Got a decent response with some very good candidates. Got a great lad on board with us.
Previous positions I struggled at advisor level, poor response, not great candidates and I had to rethink my whole plans for the team. ( previous employer)
The responses from SHP were poor and I wont use this method again, not worth the investment at all.
With the manager role above, I went directly to my contacts in the industry and this paid off.
Im absolutely confident that if IOSH reviewed its position on helping job seekers via this forum, quality candidates would find positions in all sectors of the profession.
|
|
|
|
Rank: Super forum user
|
I would say why so many people would be more interested in 'associate' work i.e. they work freelance/contract is because salaries are so much better and also in the event of redundancy will probably have more money saved up, than what they would get via Statutory redundancy calculations (being a wise freelancer - I would expect them to put money to one side for a rainy day).
If in general h&s work the staff to freelance salary ratios are about the same as the oil & gas sector - then I would expect a freelancer/contractor to earn probably in the region of 75% more by working freelance rather than permanent.
|
|
|
|
Rank: Super forum user
|
DP wrote:Im absolutely confident that if IOSH reviewed its position on helping job seekers via this forum, quality candidates would find positions in all sectors of the profession. I agree
|
|
|
|
Rank: Forum user
|
I'm not a recruiter, but am one of those candidates who has been looking for a position, for ages! I don't however apply for all and every position. I make sure my applications are targeted ones, and my covering letter reflects that. I'm not a fan of the scatter gun approach as I believe that would waste my time, and that of the potential employer too. I get daily emails from all the main recruiters for HSE roles, and that includes SHP. I don't recall seeing your advertisement, but You've not mentioned whereabouts in the Midlands you are. It's possible you were too far away for me for it to be a viable opportunity. I'm based in Derbyshire. I'd love to be given the chance to apply for a training role. The ones I've applied for typically have been aimed at the younger generation, which is not the sector I'm in. I'm now trying to pick up ad hoc work wherever I can, which isn't ideal as it's very hit and miss. I agree with Darren and Walker too. Edited by moderator 30 October 2014 16:13:38(UTC)
| Reason: Not specified
|
|
|
|
Rank: Super forum user
|
I will be looking for a position in the coming months as I am on a fixed term contract, I have always found potential employers like the fact I've got qualifications but lack experience, I was in a dead end job that I hated and had very little chance to get any health and safety experience. I must have been turned down 80 times with the same line- I understand businesses don't always have the time to train staff with little experience- I find it shame not just for myself but for others that may have real potential in the field and keep getting stumped at the first hurdle. Luckily the job I am in now is giving me some valauble experience and is supportive of me undertaking the NEBOSH Diploma off my own back too, which will hopefully help me find something else a bit more permanent.
|
|
|
|
Rank: Forum user
|
jodieclark1510 wrote:I will be looking for a position in the coming months as I am on a fixed term contract, I have always found potential employers like the fact I've got qualifications but lack experience, I was in a dead end job that I hated and had very little chance to get any health and safety experience. I must have been turned down 80 times with the same line- I understand businesses don't always have the time to train staff with little experience- I find it shame not just for myself but for others that may have real potential in the field and keep getting stumped at the first hurdle. Luckily the job I am in now is giving me some valauble experience and is supportive of me undertaking the NEBOSH Diploma off my own back too, which will hopefully help me find something else a bit more permanent. Like you, I've also been told I've got great qualifications, although I've already done level 5/6 with a bit of level 7 thrown in for good measure. It's incredibly frustrating. I hope all goes well for you with the NEBOSH diploma.
|
|
|
|
Rank: Super forum user
|
Thank you much appreciated :-)
|
|
|
|
Rank: Super forum user
|
Baker, I suspect it's a matter of too many individuals thinking that self-employment is an easy way to earn a good living and then discovering that they have more finger-twiddling time than they anticipated, thus needing to supplement their income. Also as a consultant I use associates rather than employees as I have no desire to accept the aggravation that sometimes goes along with having employees. I made that strategic decision knowing that my scope for business expansion was limited and that I would no longer be working with global organisations.
I have been self-employed now for over 12 years and whilst occasionally fully engaged, I usually have spare capacity and happy to accept "associate" work. It does not pay as well as home-grown client work but there is no development or sales time needed, it rarely gets complicated and there's always the opportunity to say "No" if I don't like the sound of the work. And it's easy to say no if the work is beyond my competence, without having to find somebody else who can do it.
As a consultant, it is very reassuring to know that I can call on others (whom I know and trust) to assist on an "as needed" basis and a good ego boost to know that the reverse is also true.
It works well for me.
|
|
|
|
Rank: Super forum user
|
I think that you have hit the problem on the head in your statement as U appear to be asking for a consultant and an employee in the same sentence where the two are not the same in my view - I advise {sorry if I am telling U to suck eggs} that all advertisements are made very clear as to what is wanted and its down to many factors e.g. those wanting employment may be put off by the word consultant and those wanting freelance will be put off by the word employee
As a freelance again myself I find it better as it suites me and would not apply for an employed post [unless the post had massive £ with it!] and I generally find that people who are every bit as good as a consultant are not as respected as a consultant is even where doing exactly the same thing!!! On the other hand employed status should bring with it more security** and yes it is a good selling point having employed staff but unfortunately clients do not really live in the real world
**NB: Note I said 'should' as times are not what they were so an employee is at more risk that they were
Best of luck in your search
|
|
|
|
Rank: Forum user
|
I am in exactly the same position,so how do we get that experience?I'm now unemployed and looking for work in a health and safety role.
|
|
|
|
Rank: New forum user
|
I am in the same boat , unemployed and desperately trying to seek any Health and Safety work.Personally funded my NEBOSH Certificate and Diploma,and all of a sudden I now have to be an expert in Quality and Environmental management, with all these made up new job titles QHSE,SHEQ etc.Anybody that has studied to NEBOSH Diploma level with or without experience should be given a chance as a trainee consultant,manager, Safety advisor.This just is not happening as potential employers seem to be raising the bar in terms of qualifications and experience.
|
|
|
|
Rank: Forum user
|
isca01 wrote:I am in the same boat , unemployed and desperately trying to seek any Health and Safety work.Personally funded my NEBOSH Certificate and Diploma,and all of a sudden I now have to be an expert in Quality and Environmental management, with all these made up new job titles QHSE,SHEQ etc.Anybody that has studied to NEBOSH Diploma level with or without experience should be given a chance as a trainee consultant,manager, Safety advisor.This just is not happening as potential employers seem to be raising the bar in terms of qualifications and experience. I have done exactly the same as you, and have environmental too. I think IOSH really really need to listen to their members, and allow job postings, so that IOSH members can help other IOSH members. After all, IOSH is supposed to be a charity. They could always have a closed forum (accesible only by paid up members).
|
|
|
|
You cannot post new topics in this forum.
You cannot reply to topics in this forum.
You cannot delete your posts in this forum.
You cannot edit your posts in this forum.
You cannot create polls in this forum.
You cannot vote in polls in this forum.