Welcome Guest! The IOSH forums are a free resource to both members and non-members. Login or register to use them

Postings made by forum users are personal opinions. IOSH is not responsible for the content or accuracy of any of the information contained in forum postings. Please carefully consider any advice you receive.

Notification

Icon
Error

Options
Go to last post Go to first unread
Rose Herridge  
#1 Posted : 07 November 2012 20:25:27(UTC)
Rank: Forum user
Rose Herridge

Good evening - Please could you give me some advice about a whiplash injury? I have been told that you can receive a whiplash injury - just by getting out of a chair?? my reason for asking is that someone i know has "bumped" at 2 or 3mph into the back of a car and now the other driver is claiming a PI of whiplash - no damage to either car also... I would be really grateful for any help that you can give Thank you in advance
MrsBlue  
#2 Posted : 08 November 2012 08:44:57(UTC)
Rank: Guest
Guest

I was in a three car shunt a couple of years ago when the car behind me was hit and pushed into mine. There was 4 people in the car none of whom were hurt. I was fully comp and claimed the damage through other car drivers. Within 2 days I was beseiged by a no win no pay solicitors in York - I live on the south coast. They badgered me for over 10 days to be in a claim for whiplash. I told them countless times that no one was injured but they virtually insisted I claim. I refused. Lots of people I guess would claim. Rich
redken  
#3 Posted : 08 November 2012 10:13:48(UTC)
Rank: Super forum user
redken

if you are in a stationary car that is hit from behind a very slow speeds then surely all the energy of the collision will be absorbed by the bumpers! What I have always thought is more likely is that the car in front starts moving then breaks suddenly and that is what causes both the whiplash and the crash from behind.
KieranD  
#4 Posted : 08 November 2012 10:22:25(UTC)
Rank: Super forum user
KieranD

Rose In relation to your statements: Please could you give me some advice about a whiplash injury? I have been told that you can receive a whiplash injury - just by getting out of a chair?? my reason for asking is that someone i know has "bumped" at 2 or 3mph into the back of a car and now the other driver is claiming a PI of whiplash - no damage to either car also... 1. Perhaps it's possible to get a 'whiplash injury' by just getting out of a chair. When I listened to one of the world's leading orthopaedic ergonomists, Steve Pheasant, shortly before his untimely death in 1996, he categorically said, 'You could get a back injury just picking up a pencil. For most of the weight on your vertebrae is the weight of your own upper torso. That's just how humans are designed'. 2. A simple, straightforward option for you is to reply. 'I hear what you say. If you would be so kind as to let me have a copy of the written diagnosis of an experienced orthopaedic surgeon or rheumatologist, I will give the matter the attention it merits'. 3. Then relax - avoid getting bored by the absence of the expert opinion you invited by finding more stimulating sources of interest and value.
David Bannister  
#5 Posted : 08 November 2012 11:06:16(UTC)
Rank: Super forum user
David Bannister

My wife drove gently in to the back of a large breakdown truck, did minor damge to her own car and the other driver didn't even know his vehicle had been hit until alerted by a pedestrian. You can guess the rest! On another occasion she was hit from the left side on a minor road roundabout in what a witness described as a staged collision. One other driver and then another three "passengers" quickly appeared from the neighbourhood. On that occasion I believe the insurers stood firm, having the benefit of two independant witnesses. There is a thriving illegal industry in claims-manufacturing. Some commentators have suggested insurance industry complaceny. More liability claims = greater demand for insurances at higher prices.
Clairel  
#6 Posted : 08 November 2012 14:45:34(UTC)
Rank: Super forum user
Clairel

Whiplash doesn't have to be from a car crash. I've had it from a skiing accident. However, getting out of a chair and getting whiplash would seem somewhat extreme as your neck would not be involved in any 'whip' type action (which is what causes the damage the head accelerating forward and back). If someone has hurt their neck getting out of the chair I would suspect that there are other factors involved. If you ask the medical profession that deal with these things they will tell you that actually those with very little damage to the car are more likely to receive a whiplash injury. Just because there are so many false claims don't disrespect the fact that whiplash is a very painful injury and one of the most common patterns is a delay of symptoms for 24-48 hrs, not immediate symptoms.
NickH  
#7 Posted : 08 November 2012 15:50:31(UTC)
Rank: Super forum user
NickH

Two scenario's from personal; experience. 1) A few years ago, whilst queuing in stationary traffic, the driver behind was possibly not paying attention and drove into the back of my car. I heard the tyres skidding and saw what was about to happen in my rear view mirror, and subsequently braced myself for impact (which was later estimated at around 20mph). No side effects whatsoever, which I can probably put down to the fact that I knew what was coming and prepared for it as best I could. 2) More recently - again whilst queuing in stationary traffic the driver behind me had a 'moment' where their foot slipped off the clutch. They hit me at possibly around 5 - 10 mph. I was completely unaware this was about to happen, and as a result, was thrown forward/ back in my seat. Approximately 18 hours later, I had difficulty in moving my neck freely and had a constant blinding headache. My assumption? Impact speed does not always determine the outcome - whether you are forewarned/ prepared does.
Clairel  
#8 Posted : 08 November 2012 16:34:30(UTC)
Rank: Super forum user
Clairel

Despite your personal experience Nick, actually bracing yourself makes it worse usually. Tight muscles are more prone to damage than loose muscles. Seat belts save lives but are the reason for the increase in whiplash injuries at low speed (so I'm led to believe) because it is just your neck that over extends and then whips back instead of the whole body being thrown forward and then back.
Users browsing this topic
Guest
You cannot post new topics in this forum.
You cannot reply to topics in this forum.
You cannot delete your posts in this forum.
You cannot edit your posts in this forum.
You cannot create polls in this forum.
You cannot vote in polls in this forum.