Welcome Guest! The IOSH forums are a free resource to both members and non-members. Login or register to use them

Postings made by forum users are personal opinions. IOSH is not responsible for the content or accuracy of any of the information contained in forum postings. Please carefully consider any advice you receive.

Notification

Icon
Error

Options
Go to last post Go to first unread
Admin  
#1 Posted : 22 December 2006 10:11:00(UTC)
Rank: Guest
Admin

Posted By steven123442
Following on from halesowen Baggie's question I have a similar query:
My sister works for a print company on a continental shift pattern (3x 12 hour days, 1x day off, 3x 12 hour days, 7 days off, then start again).
She arrived at work a couple of months ago on a rainy morning at approx 5:30am and parked her car in the (unlit) car park. Walking across the car park she slipped on some wet cardboard and damaged her hip and back. She was sent home, went to her GP and was off work for approx 5 weeks (bear in mind that she works one week in two thus missing 3 'working' weeks)
The cardboard is 'stored' in an area of the car park but obviously some had 'escaped', got wet and created a slippery surface.
Her employer told her that the company does not pay for being off sick! I told her to speak to her employer and find out if they had any procedures in place for an accident at work - reporting under RIDDOR, accident investigation, prevention of a reoccurrence of the accident, etc. She was told that all procedures had been followed but still no sick pay. I told her to go back and ask for a copy of the F2508 form. This request was met with various excuses and an offer of 12 hours pay (1 day's money).
I told her to push for at least two weeks pay (6 days/72 hours). So far she has had no luck.
Does anybody have any ideas what she should do next please?
Thank you in advance
Admin  
#2 Posted : 22 December 2006 10:21:00(UTC)
Rank: Guest
Admin

Posted By I McDonald
Stephen

as I understand things, there is no legal requirement for the employer to pay whilst your sister was absent (certainly a moral argument, caring employer I think not). Your sister needs to confirm the company stance which should be clearly dealt with in her contract of employment (if she has been given such a thing). She may want to approach the company HR Department for clarification however; if she still does not get any joy, it sounds like the only route left for her to take is via a solicitor.

Ian

P.S. hope your sister made a full recovery
Admin  
#3 Posted : 22 December 2006 10:27:00(UTC)
Rank: Guest
Admin

Posted By Bob Youel

Companies should maintain their undertakings - much case law in place

Tell her to think very hard; as accepting money like that could be seen as conniving and many other things - she really needs to know what she wants before she goes for it

Take advice re: -
1: Citizens Advice Bureau
2: Social Security office [Statutory sick pay / the need to have an accident book etc]
3: Union [If there is any]
4: Company H&S adviser [probably do not have one]
5: The HSE re RIDDOR

It looks like the company is not complying to any rules/laws - she may have to lose her job to get something back - her entitlements
Admin  
#4 Posted : 22 December 2006 10:33:00(UTC)
Rank: Guest
Admin

Posted By garyh
She should check her contract of employment / employee handbook etc for terms and conditions, which should define if sick pay is paid or not.

She may have to make a common law "compo" claim for the lost earnings.
Admin  
#5 Posted : 22 December 2006 10:43:00(UTC)
Rank: Guest
Admin

Posted By Emyr Evans
She puts in compo claim

Employers insurance company pays out eventually - 2-3 years

x2 sets of solicitors make a killing in charging for paperwork

Employer has to pay for somoen to deal with the paperwork & may get "annoyed" with employee

Simpler system in Ireland where they settle claims much faster
Admin  
#6 Posted : 22 December 2006 10:58:00(UTC)
Rank: Guest
Admin

Posted By steven123442
Thank you for your responses.

I'd like to add that I worked for this company about 5 years ago (not in an H & S position).

The health, safety and welfare of their employees is not a priority:

They have a permanent night shift (6pm-6am, same continental shift) but no regular health assessment programme.

Machinery (print machines, guillotines, mail inserting machines, etc.) is not locked off for maintenance work.

The quickest and easiest way to stop a machine (shown to me by a supervisor) is to put your hand into the machine whilst it is running. Sensor detects a break in the beam and the machine stops.

Very noisy environment (compressors, etc.), may not be over the limit but never been measured so who knows.

12 hour shift with one 20 minute break. As far as I know this is acceptable but not sure if it is right as a high level of concentration is needed.

Very poor house keeping - pallets of paper, envelopes, leaflets, etc. around machines and in walkways. There are designated areas for pallets by machines but not well managed.

I'd like to point out that I have no hidden agenda behind my question. The company treated me fairly and I left as I got a better offer elsewhere. I just think they need a kick up the backside with regards to H & S.

Ian, thank you, she hasn't made a full recovery but is getting there.
Admin  
#7 Posted : 22 December 2006 11:03:00(UTC)
Rank: Guest
Admin

Posted By garyh
"Machines not locked off for maintenance". I had to read that twice.

I would call the Factory Inspector.

You might just save some one's life.
Admin  
#8 Posted : 22 December 2006 13:44:00(UTC)
Rank: Guest
Admin

Posted By Darren J Fraser
Steve

Sounds like an anon call the HSE is in order.

I hope your sister recovers, and would suggest that she seek professional legal advice.
There are many avenues to pursue to do this including the CAB, No-win No-fee companies etc.

I would normally advise contacting the company first and discussing the situation with a senior manager, director or the owner and inform them of their responsibilities under the various pieces of legislation, as they may not be aware of their legal responsibilities, however from reading what you have written, I would guess that this would be a waste of time and breath.

If you are able to obtain pictures or video (legally) over a period of time, demonstrating various poor practice, that will assist with the building of your sisters case.
Admin  
#9 Posted : 22 December 2006 14:34:00(UTC)
Rank: Guest
Admin

Posted By John Murgatroyd
You could call the hse....but you'd have a better result calling the insurer who will be paying any liability claim.
Admin  
#10 Posted : 28 December 2006 13:56:00(UTC)
Rank: Guest
Admin

Posted By Phil Grace
Just a quick point. Your sister should not approach the employer's EL Insurer.

Civil claims for compensation as a result of workplace accidents must always be made by the injured person to the employer. It is the employer's responsibility to forward any such claim they receive to their EL insurer who will then take over the handling of the claim.
The injured person's "claim" is against their employer.
It must be remembered that buried in the wording of the Act an employer can dispense with the need to take out insurance if they lodge a bond with the appropriate Govt department - don't know of any who have done so..!!!
Admin  
#11 Posted : 28 December 2006 15:00:00(UTC)
Rank: Guest
Admin

Posted By Bill Parkinson
Number of points here.

First of all check terms and conditions of employment re sick pay.

Contact DWP to try and get incident classed as industrial injury.

If the car park is owned by the compnay then Occupiers Liability issues arise as well as HASWA (protection of other people). Also even if car park is off main site may be determined as being at work for the purposes of HASWA (some cases recently seemed to have set this).

Under CPR rules compensation claims are on average settled within 18 months (or less) from start to finish as strict timescales are required to be followed.

Ask the HSE for a copy of the F2508 as this will possibly resolve an issue as to whether the company has actually reported it to the HSE.

Make an offical complaint to the HSE setting out the details as they will give the organisation 10 days to respond or a visit will be scheduled.

Good Luck !!

Admin  
#12 Posted : 28 December 2006 15:27:00(UTC)
Rank: Guest
Admin

Posted By steven bentham
Steven123442

Whilst I feel sorry for your sister, 'a slip on some wet cardboard that has blown into the car park' should be kept in perspective.

I doubt if the HSE will rush out on this one.

I agree that the other matters may have been serious, but you did not see fit to report them to the HSE after you left!

It may seem to some that after the accident to your sister, it has caused you to remember a number of other unsafe working practices.

The ring HSE postings have overlooked the working together, consultation, self regulation approach. - Don't tell me all you that work in safety or train in safety or consult in safety have as your first response - "ring the HSE"

Admin  
#13 Posted : 28 December 2006 15:41:00(UTC)
Rank: Guest
Admin

Posted By Bill Parkinson
The response to ring the HSE is likely due to the "delay" in sending a copy of the F2508 to the injured person. Indeed the fact that some offer of "sick" pay was made only when this response was made would suggest that possibly the company had not reported it.

In light of the comment it was only one piece of cardboard then perhaps if the car park was adequately lit and waste cardboard properly secured the company would be able to mount a sufficient defence against any claim. Its actions however would suggest otherwise.
Admin  
#14 Posted : 28 December 2006 15:54:00(UTC)
Rank: Guest
Admin

Posted By steven bentham
Bill

That may be true for a civil claim, but its hardly the crime of the year!
Admin  
#15 Posted : 29 December 2006 11:36:00(UTC)
Rank: Guest
Admin

Posted By Bill Parkinson
I recall a similar case for a public organisation a few years ago which did not want to give a copy of the F2508 to the injured party. When they contacted the HSE the reason why was clear they hadn't reported it!! Result £ 100,000 fine !
Admin  
#16 Posted : 29 December 2006 12:10:00(UTC)
Rank: Guest
Admin

Posted By steven bentham
I bet that did wonders for health and safety.
Admin  
#17 Posted : 29 December 2006 22:58:00(UTC)
Rank: Guest
Admin

Posted By martin gray1
Hi Steven
Sorry to hear about your sisters accident it could have happened to anyone of us.

As a General Manager, HS & HR I have to deal with such claims. I try to look at it from the point of view the individual concerned did not ask to be injured when they came to work that day. We all have bills to pay and accidents cause hardships to all concerned.

If it becomes a long term issue it will normally result in a legal claim. I then try to be as helpful as possible to everybody concerned to bring the matter to a speedy conclusion. I try to learn from the incident and prevent a recurrence. I certainly do not hold a grudge against one of my most valuable assets my member of staff who did not ask to be harmed.

We pay insurance to cover such situations and if you are doing things correctly a one off accident like this will not send your premium soaring through the roof.

Her employer builds his insurance premium into his overheads or he should do. I suggest she takes advise and then decides what action she wants to take. If she does decide on a legal claim she should not suffer any victimisation over such a claim and if she does she has employment rights.

Wish her well, we do not all follow their thinking.

MG
Admin  
#18 Posted : 30 December 2006 12:28:00(UTC)
Rank: Guest
Admin

Posted By SURE24LTD
SURE24 LIMITED
Registered No. 04863038
2 PRIORY MEWS, FISHER LANE,
BINGHAM, NOTTINGHAM,
NG13 8BQ
WE ARE RUNNING A PROMO OF BUY 5 GET ONE FREE

BUSINESS PROPOSAL LETTER.
We have all brands of Mobile Phones,Ipods,Sidekicks,Nextels phone,Laptops and plasma tv for sell at cheap and affordable prices, they rangesfromNokia/Samsung/LG/Sony Ericsson/Motorola/Alcatel/panasonic With Bluetooth, all
Brands and Models of Nextel Phones, we want you to get back
to us with your quote so that we can begin a good business
relationship. Note they are all Brand New T2 Euro specs,
unlocked, no operator logo, come in their
original sealed box, With 1 year international warranty
from the manufacturer, English & Spanish manual, Finland
made.
We want to assure you that you will never regret buying
from us because the delivery will be to your doorstep via
FedEx,Dhl and Ups Courier services.And the Tracking number shall be sentto you upon acknowledgement of your payment.
Kindly acknowledge the reciept of our mail and get back to
us at SURE2LTD@HOTMAIL.CO.UK

LISTED BELOW:
SAMSUNG D730 For......$140usd
SAMSUNG D800 FOR......$145usd
SAMSUNG D820 For......$150usd
Sony Ericsson W950i For......$200usd
SONY ERICSSON P900 For......$140usd
Sony Ericsson P910i For......$150usd
Sony Ericsson p990i For......$180usd
NOKIA 8800 For........$220usd
NOKIA N90 For.........$160usd
NOKIA N91 For.........$170usd
NOKIA N92 For.........$200usd
NOKIA N93 For.........$250usd
NOKIA N95 For.........$350usd
SIDEKICK 2 for........$140usd
SIDEKICK 3 for........$180usd
MOTOROLA RAZOR V3 for........$130usd
MOTOROLA RAZOR V6 FOR........$140usd
Qtek 9600--$250
Qtek 9000--$230
Qtek 8310--$200
Qtek 9100--$270
Qtek 9090--$200
02 xDA Exec--$280
02 XDA Atom--$260
Treo 700--$200
Treo 600--$150
Treo 650--$160
I-MATE JAMin--$240
I-MATE JASJAR-$280
I-MATE K-JAM--$180
TomTom GO 700-----230usd
TomTom GO 910-----240usd
TomTom RIDER-----.-250usd
Xbox 360 Premium @ 180USD
Nintendo Wii @ $150USD
Sony PSP Giga Pack @ $100USD
Sony Mylo @ $110usd
Dell Xps M1710 @ $450USD
Dell Xps M2010 @ $500USD
Apple 4 GB ipod Mini Blue M9802LL/A----$95USD
Apple 4 GB iPod Mini Pink M9804LL/A----$90USD
Apple 4 GB iPod Mini Green M9806LL/A----$90USD
Apple 6 GB iPod Mini Blue M9803LL/A?------$100USD
Apple 6 GB iPod Mini Silver M9801LL/A-----$100USD
Apple 20 GB iPod photo===$100USD
Apple 30 GB iPod Photo====$110USD
Apple 40 GB iPod photo====$120USD
Apple 60 GB iPod photo====$140USD
Apple Ipod Nano 2GB...$60USD
Apple Ipod Nano 4GB.....$80USD
Apple Ipod video 30GB.....$15USd
Apple Ipod video 60GB.....$200USD
Apple Ipod video 80GB(NEW)..$250USD
Pioneer AVIC-Z1 Car DVD Player-----$650usd
Pioneer AVIC-N3 Car DVD Player-----$450usd
Pioneer AVIC-N2 Car DVD Player---$400usd
Creative Labs ZEN Vision W (60 GB) Digital Media Player-----$250USD
Creative Labs Nomad Jukebox Zen Xtra (40 GB) MP3 Player-----$180USD
Creative Technology Zen Micro Plus (8GB) Black MP3 Player--------$150usd
Sony DCR-DVD403 Digital Camcoders.......530usd
Sony DCR-HC18 Digital Camcoders ......200usd
Sony DCR-SR50 Digital Camcoders.......665usd
Sony DCR-DVD405 Digital Camcoders.... ..665usd
Sony DCR-HC44 Digital Camcoders.......230usd
Sony DCR-SR30 Digital Camcoders.......435usd

Sony VAIO TX770 (VGNTX770PB) PC Notebook........$500
Acer Ferrari 5005WLMi (LXFR506119) PC Notebook..$600usd

Pioneer PDP-5060HD 50 in. Plasma Television--------------$800
Samsung HP-S5053 50 in. HDTV Plasma Television----------$1000
Panasonic TH-50PX60U 50 in. HDTV Plasma Television------$900
Sony KDE-42XS955 42 in. HDTV Plasma Television----------$950
JVC PD-50X795 50 in. HDTV Plasma Television ------------$1000
Philips 50PF7320A 50 in. HDTV Plasma Television---------$400
NEC PX-61XM4A Plasma Display $750 ----------------------$450
Toshiba 50HP66 50 in. Plasma Television-----------------$500


WE SHIP OUR VIA FEDEX,DHL AND UPS AND IT TAKES 2-3DAYS TO GET TO YOUR DOORSTEP.
A SERIOUS BUYER SHOULD CONTACT US VIA EMAIL:sure2ltd@hotmail.co.uk/sure2lltd@yahoo.co.uk OR sure2ltd@enterto.com
REGARD,
MGT.
Admin  
#19 Posted : 04 January 2007 10:03:00(UTC)
Rank: Guest
Admin

Posted By steven123442
Have just logged on following the holidays and thank you all very much for your responses. I will pass this information on to my sister.

Steve Bentham, thank you also for your comments but I would just like to point out that my sister's accident wasn't just 'a slip on some wet cardboard that has blown into the car park' and at the time I worked at this organisation I wasn't an H & S professional.

Thanks again,
Steve
Admin  
#20 Posted : 04 January 2007 14:19:00(UTC)
Rank: Guest
Admin

Posted By Merv Newman
Re comment on "machines not locked off for maintenance"

This appears to be standard practice in industry. Maintenance people sort of throw themselves at a broken down machine with the objective of getting it back into production as fast as possible. Lock-off ? your joking.

I know what I mean when I'm talking lock-off : Lock, Tag, Clear, Try (with a REAL padlock) How many of you manage to get that adopted as standard practice ?

Sorry, it's a bit off the "slipped on cardboard in the car park" original posting but it was an opportunity to vent one of my hot buttons.

Merv
Admin  
#21 Posted : 19 January 2007 14:10:00(UTC)
Rank: Guest
Admin

Posted By steven123442
Quick update on my sister's accident at work:

She has been paid the two weeks wages she asked for...no explanation, no discussion.

Seems to me that the HR department saw this as a way to cover their backsides as I do believe the company's duty of care was found to be flawed.

Thanks again for reading my question and your responses.
Users browsing this topic
Guest
You cannot post new topics in this forum.
You cannot reply to topics in this forum.
You cannot delete your posts in this forum.
You cannot edit your posts in this forum.
You cannot create polls in this forum.
You cannot vote in polls in this forum.