Rank: Guest
|
Posted By Anne Stephens
Hi
wondering if any of you scaffold bods can help. We have had an incident where one of our guys had a shock while erecting a scaffold. He touched a metal cable tray. The client has checked all the earths and voltages and it is all fine. They are putting it down to static as he was wearing rubber soled safety boots and working on plastic scaffold boards.
Have you ever heard of this before or has it happened in your company?
I'm a bit concerned as we are moving more to plastic boards due to the manual handling issue and also because of the nature of the clients work, as wood is costly to dispose of.
Thanks in advance
Anne
|
|
|
|
Rank: Guest
|
Posted By Martin Daly
This almost certainly has more to do with what the scaffolder was wearing than the plastic scaffold boards.
The boards are in contact with steel scaffolding so can build up a charge. Also there must be friction between the plastic and something else.
Martin Daly
|
|
|
|
Rank: Guest
|
Posted By Garry Adams
Anne
The composition of these boards have limited advantages over the organic timber boards i.e. they do not absorb water thus making them lighter for manual handling and the resistant to rot.
However, the composition of these boards are susceptible to cracks (rendering them Un-Servisable)over a comparatively short period of service, these boards require a greater degree of manual handling, they do not like rough handling.
I do not wish to bad mouth this product, however, it is my personal view that it takes something exceptional to improve on the status quo (organic boards), beware of false economies in the name of progress.
The static shock may have been generated by a combination of the speed at which the Scaffold Erector was working, a build up of ferrous particles from the metal tube deposited on the surface of the board and the sweat acting as a conductor.
Garry...
|
|
|
|
Rank: Guest
|
Posted By willhiem
Cant see it being the boards somehow. as Martin said more likely to do with what he was wearing etc. could even be a mobile phone if you believe they can create that much static!
plastic boards / wooden boards / metal ones they all have there pro's and cons, though i cant see the plastic ones taking over too soon, too many questions, thought the fact you can recycle them is a pretty big plas.
so to sum up, i havent really helped at all just threw in my tupence worth, sorry ;-)
|
|
|
|
Rank: Guest
|
Posted By Jane Blunt
I suspect it may be the boards. It is common experience that walking across an insulating material (such as a nylon carpet) can result in the human being and the carpet becoming electrically charged. The human being may well experience a shock when they touch something that is a conductor (such as a light switch).
This may be what has happened here. The scaffold boards would be good isulators.
Jane
|
|
|
|
Rank: Guest
|
Posted By andy tetlow
hi anne
i spoke to our scaffolders, who have been using these plastic boards and none have ever come across a static /electric shock from them.
our scaffs always where gloves so that might be a factor.
our lads dont particularly like these boards. they have had in the past issues over the ends of the boards, when they are not capped, tools/ welding rods getting stored in them.
also they are slightly thicker than a conventional wooden board which means different types of board clips to be bought.
and as said before they can be brittle, we have had issues with cracks in boards too.
regards
andy t
|
|
|
|
Rank: Guest
|
Posted By Garry Adams
when the plastic boards are rendered U.S. it is of no further use other than to be sent to be recycled at a cost to th Organisation Carbon Foot Print and to the cost of replacing the board.
A conventional Standard Scaffolding Board when damaged can be cut down to size and re-banded.
Given the option ...I would use the conventional Scaff Board every time...
Anne...consult your Scaffs before you buy replacements.
Garry...
|
|
|
|
Rank: Guest
|
Posted By Anne Stephens
Thanks to all who replied. After an investigation we have just put it down to a build up of static by the scaffolder (asked him if he had put his underwear in the tumble dryer)
While I agree that plastic boards aren't as good as wood, we have a disposal issue with wood on our clients site (a certain storage site is getting full and no-one wants to build a deep one) so plastic is seen as the best option at the moment
Thanks
Anne
|
|
|
|
You cannot post new topics in this forum.
You cannot reply to topics in this forum.
You cannot delete your posts in this forum.
You cannot edit your posts in this forum.
You cannot create polls in this forum.
You cannot vote in polls in this forum.