Thanks for the lnk, Chris. Discussion of this case is not permitted under the rules of the site: "Discussion of potential or actual legal proceedings is prohibited on the public discussion forums. Public inquiries may be discussed, including where IOSH is a party to the Inquiry, on the Members’ Forum. Information that has been intentionally released, for example to alert others to a particular hazard or fact, can also be discussed in the IOSH Members’ Forum." This topic will therefore be locked. Jane