Welcome Guest! The IOSH forums are a free resource to both members and non-members. Login or register to use them

Postings made by forum users are personal opinions. IOSH is not responsible for the content or accuracy of any of the information contained in forum postings. Please carefully consider any advice you receive.

Notification

Icon
Error

Options
Go to last post Go to first unread
Victor Meldrew  
#1 Posted : 09 February 2011 11:41:22(UTC)
Rank: Guest
Guest

Apologies in advance for this, but just got to put pen to paper so to speak and get it ‘off my chest’. Had a coffee with a very close friend yesterday morning for an hour or so, who has retired from work, and as you do just chewing the cud. Very rarely do we talk about my industry/work but the topic came up as he knows I’m ‘winding down’ as it were, and additionally, I mentioned that I’d had two calls and one email from H&S people made redundant in the last week, which was ‘playing on my mind’. What concerns me is what he said in that he reckoned; “it will probably be the ‘thin end of the wedge’ and you probably ain’t seen nothing yet”. He went on to mention things like, recent press and media coverage on relaxation on H&S ‘rules’, likely changes in legislation, low risk workplaces no longer required to do RA’s and HSEs online RAs, you know the kind of stuff we’ve all heard recently. He continued on; “which all then means that companies/businesses will relax somewhat in that they will no longer see the importance of ‘managing’ H&S and that safety will not be high on their priority list……..” of course with some it never is/was eh?. So relating to the three redundant contacts that I’ve recently heard from; I don’t think I should be advising them to ‘stick’ with H&S with families/mortgages to consider and would you recommend anyone thinking of entering H&S career to even bother? I believe that if this is the way my close friend ‘sees’ things…. and he’s not alone I guess, then my goodness what are the leaders and those with influence of SMEs thinking? It was bad enough before all the recent information / misinformation but when anything is relaxed including H&S, IMHO it takes a long, long, long time to re-engage and recover. Personal experience confirms the ‘bad times’, I’ve not been able to give any work to a couple of associates who help me out for almost a year now……. one IS changing careers….. if he can. The phone just doesn’t ring, the emails don’t ‘land’. Ok for me as I fit into a ‘niche’ market and I’ve got just a nice bit of work for as long as I want it, but blimey it’s a good job I don’t need the work otherwise I’d be like so many others I reckon. So the point I’m making and question is, is it the ‘thin end of the wedge’? Would you tell those poor unfortunates who’ve been made redundant to ‘stick at it’, ‘soldier on’ or would you advise then to change industry/career? And if it is the latter, if/when ‘things’ pick up where will all the H&S professionals be? I suppose they’ll be on the OSHCR…..waiting for the call….. This OSHCR is surely going to be bit of a ‘white elephant’ because we’re probably not going to be needed……soon anyway. Sorry folks, worst time I’ve seen/heard/experienced in 28 years and hate to be the doom and gloom merchant, always try to look on the bright side but where do ‘we’ go from here and what’s the answer.......? If there is one.
freelance safety  
#2 Posted : 09 February 2011 11:52:52(UTC)
Rank: Super forum user
freelance safety

In almost twenty years I’ve never known things this bad. I’ve seen many companies make professionals redundant and the salaries drop significantly. I genuinely believe though that we have bottomed out and that things will and are picking-up. For new blood this is going to be incredibly difficult for them to gain that all important first step on the health And safety career ladder. I think we will see a transitional change in how we promote our profession and how we manage as professionals. I believe that the profession will always need new people and therefore there will be a place for trainees. The issue will be the economic climate prevailing and the level of recovery. Jobs will be available, just less of them.
Nick House  
#3 Posted : 09 February 2011 11:53:29(UTC)
Rank: Guest
Guest

To be fair, I don't think this is just associated with the H&S industry. I know of FM's that are in the same boat, and also several people in HR. I think that as a country we are a fair way before we are out of the woods, and businesses as a whole are still looking at a way to steady the bottom line. Construction is still a precarious industry to be in for example, as is engineering.
Victor Meldrew  
#4 Posted : 09 February 2011 11:59:23(UTC)
Rank: Guest
Guest

Freelance / Nick - thanks, I think you're about right in what you both say.....you've certainly made me feel a bit better and hopefully I can pass on some 'positives' to those less fortunate than myself. Chin up I suppose and that good 'ol saying 'keep calm and carry on'.
PhilBeale  
#5 Posted : 09 February 2011 12:01:31(UTC)
Rank: Super forum user
PhilBeale

What career path is every going to be the right one in recession all sectors are being hit so it doesn't matter what you do for a living it will always affect you in some form or another. manufacturing fell on it's needs decades ago as the then Government saw banking and finance as the way they wanted the country to go now that has failed they are trying to rekindle manufacturing. i would say there has been a step rise in the need for H&S professionals as it is seen as a critical part of running any business when 10-20 years ago no-one really cared about the welfare of the workforce. i believe time have changed but when need to apply a good deal of common sense and not prevent business from making money due to over complicated or prohibitive H&S procedure that are over the top. Phil
Ian Mitchell  
#6 Posted : 09 February 2011 12:28:10(UTC)
Rank: Forum user
Ian Mitchell

'Victor' et al I think the best thing for H&S professionals to do is to broaden their skillset. Has anybody noticed the steady but inexorable move towards SQE, SHEQ, QHSE [whatever you want to call it!] over time. I have only been a full time practitioner since '05 but even I have noticed it. I have taken on gladly the 'Q' and 'E' elements in the intervening period and obtained appropriate bolt- on qualifications and experience. Integrated Management Systems Management is the way to go as you can convince those with the money that H&S can play a part in increasing efficiencies and reducing the bottom line. You can also prove it later on when processes etc are combined and streamlined. I understand how many H&S bods are loathe to become a 'jack of all trades' type, but even the stalwarts must see that to remain in demand in 2011 you must have something extra to 'sell'. We are going to have to fight our corners if we are to stave off the treble threat of relaxed legislation, less cash on the table and the 'bonkers' culture. Push the 'commercial' side too i.e. obtaining accreditations and registrations for new client bases such as Link Up to get into Rail and so on. Keeps you busy and opens up more opportunities for the business. I have made a point of having our certificates handed over at local Chamber of Commerce type events. Set up linkedin type sites and keep a company brochure in your glove box not just a copy of HASAWA!! I no longer see, or market myself, as an H&S Guy only. Thankfully, I landed my best job to date last year on that premise. Keep the faith, offer more and distance yourself from that 'ooh, you can't do that' mentality. Good luck one and all...
Victor Meldrew  
#7 Posted : 09 February 2011 12:44:00(UTC)
Rank: Guest
Guest

Know what you mean Ian - I was H&S, then E and then saw the Q on the horizon and decided to take a retirment package as I didn't fancy it....that was back in 2000......! Since then, guess what...? I've had to get some 'Q' qualifications to respond to the clients request, oh well, less haste more speed.
chris.packham  
#8 Posted : 09 February 2011 12:54:52(UTC)
Rank: Super forum user
chris.packham

Is it all really doom and gloom, or are we talking ourselves into a depression? In my work I deal with a very wide range of different occupational sectors. Some sectors are finding the going very tough, others are doing well. I have one client who has recently added a third shift and week-end working, just to keep up with incoming orders. Even in the same occupational sector one company may be doing well, the other in difficulties. Sure we are economically not in the best of shape but has anyone seen the Midlands Today reports on TV recently on how Midlands engineering is enjoying significant growth and having a problem finding skilled people to meet their needs? As for people not taking health and safety seriously, regulatory aspects have never been a major driver in my particular sector, so I doubt whether changes described will have much impact, but I have never had so much interest and business as I have now. Chris
Thundercliffe26308  
#9 Posted : 09 February 2011 13:06:43(UTC)
Rank: Forum user
Thundercliffe26308

I am sure we didnt all get born into our role we have a had ajourney ir two mine has been exciting and challenging .........labourer.......HMforces.......construction..........education....health safety and security....health and safety....we all have to change and adapt our knowledge and learn new skills...or we miight as well pack up and go home....(which i wouldnt mind today its quite nice)
SteveL  
#10 Posted : 09 February 2011 13:18:05(UTC)
Rank: Super forum user
SteveL

I am sure that there is a lot of businesses out there struggling to find work, but there are a lot that have so much work they are struggling to keep up. All businesses need to be efficient. HSEQ plays a big part in this. We all need to adapt to the new, long gone are the days of "you cant do that" the days of "how about we do this" are here, bring on the new, if it means bye bye to the dictatorship
Victor Meldrew  
#11 Posted : 09 February 2011 14:11:31(UTC)
Rank: Guest
Guest

Thanks for the positive words of encouragement Chris & Steve - I must admit 'I'm alright Jack' but if you have work that you can pass on to someone or know businesses that need people, I obviously know three individuals and their families who would welcome the news/opportunity. If so, please PM so I can forward on.
JonB  
#12 Posted : 09 February 2011 15:09:14(UTC)
Rank: Forum user
JonB

This tread has tickled me in a morbid humour sense (apologies to anyone who is struggling to find / lost work or facing an uncertain future). I have faced an uphill struggle to gain resources for H&S, often looking for and trying new arguments. There was a rather upbeat account of our recent change in ownership and plans for the future (apparently our sector has experienced consistent 6% + growth despite the recession(s) and we have plans to expand into Europe). The greater part of our revenue comes from enabling our customers to comply with today's H&S, environmental and other legislation. Funny that while any reduction in the H&S burden on our business will be welcomed, we stand to lose far more as other businesses find they have a reduced or no need of our services. No points for guessing whose job will be at the top of the list to chop!! I may not love the 'current' job I am in but I'm still passionate about the subject. Expanding skills gives the best chance of survival. Anyone noticed that 'green' issues are becoming big business and have been afforded a fair amount of protection from cuts etc. Things may change but my money is development in this sector. I'll keep a foot wedged in the door to the H&S office but I have just dipped my Big toe in that vast expanse that is the environmental sector.
stephenjs  
#13 Posted : 09 February 2011 15:29:58(UTC)
Rank: Forum user
stephenjs

HI guys, A good thread but you can't wait for the phone to ring, you have to go out and get the work. There has been a step change in advertising over the last three years and its the companies that do the smart marketing that are getting the work - personally I've never been so busy, having said that I wouldn't take on any staff due to the over riding 9 to 5 work mentallity
kevbell  
#14 Posted : 09 February 2011 15:40:00(UTC)
Rank: Forum user
kevbell

JonB I like your thinking I have only been in H&S for five years but have seen a big part of my work going more and more to the green side and I am looking at further training in all things environmental ,got to keep up with the times Kev
DP  
#15 Posted : 09 February 2011 16:12:15(UTC)
Rank: Super forum user
DP

Hiya - its not just bad for managers of safety - enforcers are in the mix too with redundancies - I head up the safety function for a big organisation with many site in most major UK cities - I don’t have Lead or Primary Authority so I deal with many EHO's on a weekly basis and even their statutory positions are under threat. Some have gone!!!! It grim out there.
Ian Mitchell  
#16 Posted : 09 February 2011 16:54:14(UTC)
Rank: Forum user
Ian Mitchell

As a footnote to my earlier posting about widening skills, I had to take a position as a stand- alone H&S Manager in my last job due to a sudden redundancy and the need to keep bread on the table. It was part of an 'SQE' team, but when the order books fell off there too, no prizes for guessing which bit of the fat was trimmed!
Corfield35303  
#17 Posted : 09 February 2011 17:08:13(UTC)
Rank: Forum user
Corfield35303

Its hard times for lots of people, Anybody relying on the phone to ring is in for a hard time, especially with more public sector cuts coming, and people in some SME's will soon figure that H&S is not rocket science and the bulk of H&S can be done in-house. But good H&S people will always be in demand, and the trick is to be good, and offer added value. There are a small number of enthusiastic amateurs out there offering their services thinking a NEBOSH cert is their dream ticket (check the yellow pages under H&S consultancies if in doubt, then check their websites), and these people will suffer unless they are offering specific niche services. Would I recommend H&S? Yes, the move to a more controlled, regulated and professional service is good. I disuade some people who think it is an easy move, but for the people who see developing their career over a 5 year period or longer, to become professional and are keen to learn and put in the hard work then there will be opportunities. Unfortunately with the econoy the way it is it could be difficult for some to get that first paid job and even the good consultants could struggle if there isnt the money around.....
Clairel  
#18 Posted : 09 February 2011 20:11:13(UTC)
Rank: Super forum user
Clairel

Hello strangers. A rare post for me. As people know I couldn't find work and so started a different franchise business recently, so this is a subject close to my heart really. However, my not getting work was down to several factors: my location, my inability to sell my services but also possibly a disillusionment with the H&S. I think the job market is tough at the moment but not just in H&S. I know lots of people who have been made redundant. It's affecting all sectors not just H&S. Having said that I think H&S is facing changes. I think H&S will get more and more integrated into other roles as a cost cutting measure and becuase it is still seen as an easy subject that anyone can do as a side line to their orignial role or as a combination of another role or two such as quality and environment. I'm not sure this is a good time to get into H&S becuase it is a time of such change that it won't offer stability. I wouldn't recommend the career to anyone at this time. Sorry. Personally, I am really enjoying the break from H&S. Not sure where my future lies anymore. Perhaps not here. Time will tell.
Bob Shillabeer  
#19 Posted : 09 February 2011 21:44:33(UTC)
Rank: Super forum user
Bob Shillabeer

Tried to stay away from this one, but. I was made redundant almost a year ago from a post called the Business Systems Advisor at a company conected to the Rail Industry. My main role was not H&S although about half of my work was very closely linked to it. I worked alongside a guy who was responsible for the quality side of things by setting quality procedures with those who made them work and I checked that they were being followed. Therefore there was quite avariety of work to be done. This was trimmed down last year and I was made redundant (not forced but taken with both hands after 45 years). This shows that there are some employers out there who have been looking to reduce the total H&S aspect of tasks and mixing them with other disciplines such as quality management provided the quality side is supplemented with some sort of H&S knowledge such as NEBOSH Certificate, it is wroth remebring that many companies will simply lok to comply with the law and let other H&S issues muddle along until things get better and then try and catch up. This means the future although bleak now will get better, perhaps I will be to old by then but the younger persons in the field should keep thier hopes up and learn additional skills while they can.
redken  
#20 Posted : 10 February 2011 10:04:49(UTC)
Rank: Super forum user
redken

"Record breaking month for Leicestershire-based H&S headquarters The world’s leading body for health and safety professionals, based in Leicestershire, has seen 573 members join its ranks this January - a record-breaker for the organisation."
JonB  
#21 Posted : 10 February 2011 16:26:14(UTC)
Rank: Forum user
JonB

Redken I don't want to sound cynical but could this have something to do with the consultants register? Perhaps people joining to start IPD and gain chartered stats who would not otherwise have bothered? That's not to say its a bad thing if it means more are progressing beyond the basic level and reaching a higher level of competence. It doesn't necessarily mean a higher demand for their services in industry?
Phillip Clarke  
#22 Posted : 10 February 2011 18:27:47(UTC)
Rank: Forum user
Phillip Clarke

In stark terms there is still a problem with gaining a H&S job. Just compare SHP from this month to issues from 3 - 4 years ago. Very few jobs advertised. Similarly one will find a paucity of H&S roles offered by recruitment agencies. Is it worth leaving our industry? No. But I think we need to widen the skills we can offer - E and Q seem to be the extra letters that are on job ads these days. Lord Young's, erm, 'interesting' report was a potential bad sign for H&S. But he has gone and the bad publicity he caused has, I think, lessened the impact of his report. The OSHCR is, in my opinion, a basic move in the right direction. I am hopeful, but not confident, that in the next few years it will help drive out the poor H&S consultants that unfortunately do exist. We need the HSE and LA enforcement officers to guide organisations to the OSHCR and their publications to bang on about this register. I am trying to be glass half full on this issue - it is difficult though! On the HSE and LAs there may be more opportunities if 'earned autonomy' is ever implemented. Maybe consultants on the OSHCR will be allowed to sign off self assessments by companies that have a good track record, leaving enforcement officers to focus on the bad organisations? I also subscribe to the view that in 2 - 3 years we will see a boom in H&S recruitment as companies try and catch up after letting things slip during the recession. Overall I think we need to widen out skills and try and ride out the next year or so.
Victor Meldrew  
#23 Posted : 10 February 2011 20:22:44(UTC)
Rank: Guest
Guest

Many thanks for the responses and a lot of good points made, especially on Q & E, I can certainly pass these on to those less fortunate than myself. I for one have seen a demand from my exisiting clients for the 'E' in recent years and latterly work on the related Achilles audit. Mentioned to one other individual this afternoon about E quals and he's desperate to add to his 'bow' but an embargo on training currently..... which is not unusual I suppose given the current 'climate'. The three people I've heard from recently that have hit bad times are from the South West, South East and the Midlands with the industries covered being construction, engineering and local government - so an even spread. All directly employed, not consultants. Additionally, none being replaced to my knowledge by consultants, in two cases roles being absorbed with one not knowing. Certainly, as the country begins to pull out of the recession from a couple of years ago, I should think and sincerely hope, 'we' are more in demand and the comment on job adverts in the SHP may be a future 'signal'. I certainly won't be taking much notice of IOSH membership as a guage on the job market One good thing that has come out of this thread is that one of the 'redundant' people who contacted me has obtained an interview - makes me feel warm anyway.
Users browsing this topic
Guest
You cannot post new topics in this forum.
You cannot reply to topics in this forum.
You cannot delete your posts in this forum.
You cannot edit your posts in this forum.
You cannot create polls in this forum.
You cannot vote in polls in this forum.