Welcome Guest! The IOSH forums are a free resource to both members and non-members. Login or register to use them

Postings made by forum users are personal opinions. IOSH is not responsible for the content or accuracy of any of the information contained in forum postings. Please carefully consider any advice you receive.

Notification

Icon
Error

2 Pages<12
Options
Go to last post Go to first unread
Admin  
#41 Posted : 29 June 2009 15:25:00(UTC)
Rank: Guest
Admin

Posted By CFT
John that was an interesting closiing para. I've read it a couple of times to make sure I hadn't made a mistake.

Without dragging up all the comparisons of qualification, I have over the years met some extermely competant certificate holders who I would not hesitate to offer a senior position to.

CFT
Admin  
#42 Posted : 29 June 2009 15:41:00(UTC)
Rank: Guest
Admin

Posted By John Fraser
CFT

So have I.

John
Admin  
#43 Posted : 29 June 2009 15:53:00(UTC)
Rank: Guest
Admin

Posted By Alexander Falconer
Got to agree with CFT's comments

In saying this, I have actually managed to obtain Middle & Senior Management roles with holding just NGC (gained in 97), however can back this up with other qualifications including SVQ level 5 Operational Management, Environmental Diploma, Engineering Degree, SVQ level 4 Quality Management, etc, as well as over 20 years engineering & industry experience.

Its up any employer to decide whether (or not) I would be classed as being competent enough for their needs (not had any complaints so far).

I would never classify myself as being overly perfect in what I do, the key is to acknowledge your strengths and weaknesses, and never be afraid to call upon other's expertise where required.

And yes, I have done the Diploma (awaiting results Aug 28th). Hoping to do a MSc in September through Robert Gordon University.

Even when the job markets are tight, it can be done, its just how you apply yourself, your knowledge and ensure any employer benefits from your achievements.

Also dont forget to network.........!

Alex



Admin  
#44 Posted : 29 June 2009 16:08:00(UTC)
Rank: Guest
Admin

Posted By Swis
But employers look at applicant’s records such as qualifications, memberships, experience etc in order to make their evaluations of someone’s competence. No-one and NO-ONE has the tendency to rightly guess someone’s competency level by just looking at their face. Not to forget that most employers are unaware of H&S knowledge themselves.
Admin  
#45 Posted : 29 June 2009 16:15:00(UTC)
Rank: Guest
Admin

Posted By Alexander Falconer
Swis

I have got to state, you have hit the nail on the head..............!

The perception of many employers H&S job adverts "must have NEBOSH Diploma or equivalent", all very fine and well if you are medium/high risk industry, but is this necessary for a low risk industry "dont know, but we'll state the Diploma anyway"

NGC will in my opinion be adequate for many low risk industries.

After all the Management Regs do not state what qualifications the competent person must hold.

Alex

Admin  
#46 Posted : 29 June 2009 16:23:00(UTC)
Rank: Guest
Admin

Posted By Jim Walker
I'd agree with Alex.
Most companies do not need anything more.
Its also an essential first step on the ladder to further things.

Just look at who NEBOSH say the NGC is aimed at.

The NGC has never (by NEBOSH) been claimed as a qualification for H&S professionals.
Admin  
#47 Posted : 29 June 2009 16:27:00(UTC)
Rank: Guest
Admin

Posted By Jim Walker
Swiss, what you say is true.

However an unfair fact of life is presented when I have 100 job applications in front of me

How do I quickly find who to employ??
Admin  
#48 Posted : 29 June 2009 16:41:00(UTC)
Rank: Guest
Admin

Posted By andymak
Hmmmmm, so the debate still rages!

As previously said I am more than happy to upskill although with the following skills and experience:

NRSWA Supervisor,
Legionella Technician,
Ladder inspector,
DSE assessor,
F&R trained fire risk assessor,
Workplace first aider,
experienced auditor,
behavioural safety trainer,
risk assessment, and experience of H&S management in a national, regional and departmental capacity.

I am not really sure what other skills would be useful. If someone can advise I would appreciate it.
I want to be CMIOSH, I have oodles of experience, I have both public and private sector experience.

All I need is a job now to enable me to afford to do a higher qualification!
Admin  
#49 Posted : 29 June 2009 23:33:00(UTC)
Rank: Guest
Admin

Posted By Toe
HI,

May I apologise for not responding sooner. In general if you achieve a qualification no one can take it away from you, therefore as a technicality may I take back my comment “If the Certificate is over 5 Years old then it is redundant”.

In essence some qualifications require to be refreshed for example FLT license and First Aider’s, and I fully understand and totally agree to this concept. However some awarding bodies state that their qualification run out after a certain period of time, IOSH Managing Safely is a good example of this, whereas the qualification is only valid for 3 years and requires to be refreshed thereafter.

Last year I achieved distinction grades for FC1 and FC2 (NEBOSH Fire Safety and Risk Management Certificate) but unfortunately I did not receive the full qualification because my NEBOSH Certificate was over 5 years old, and NEBOSH stated that I had to take NGC1 to receive the full parchment.

I contacted NEBOSH to explain that I had the NEBOSH part1 Diploma (less than 5 years), SVQ Level 4, and recently passed the IOSH peer open book exam (set and marked by NEBOSH) and they stated that rules were rules (i.e. a condition of Ofqual), and I required to do NGC1. Eventually after contact with NEBOSH Chief Executive they agreed to award me the full parchment certificate, but with limited grade.

This is not a dig at NEBOSH and I am well over my issues with them.

Is the NEBOSH Cert now redundant?......... discuss!

Maybe not redundant, but when I passed mine in 1999 it was probably a more sought after qualification to have on the CV than it is today.

Good luck on the job hunting Andy.
Admin  
#50 Posted : 30 June 2009 08:38:00(UTC)
Rank: Guest
Admin

Posted By Alexander Falconer
Toe

Thanks for your clarification, the picture all becomes that much clearer.

This is probably another prime example where beaurocracy should have been overruled and common sense prevailed.

Other chartered institutions seem to take each issue on its own merits, and consider the decision appropriate to the situation.

Once again, this is also another member who would have benefitted from achieving CMIOSH by the mature candidate route

This has previously been discussed to a death and I do not wish to distract from the original question

http://www.iosh.co.uk/in...iew&forum=2&thread=18407

As previous posters state, there are many holders of the NGC with many years experience that will be considered over those who have Diploma's. Again there seems to be a need to develop an additional CMIOSH route without devaluing the existing routes to CMIOSH.

Andymak, I am sure that something will happen, keep plugging away

Alex
Admin  
#51 Posted : 03 July 2009 10:35:00(UTC)
Rank: Guest
Admin

Posted By andymak
Once again many thanks to all for the lively and open debate.
Admin  
#52 Posted : 16 July 2009 23:16:00(UTC)
Rank: Guest
Admin

Posted By andymak
Am now starting to get the occassional enquiry about possible short term work, but still nothing solid, as most jobs still seem to want Dip, I am noticing more jobs are looking for a degree as desirable as well as the dip, which I find a bit worrying!
Admin  
#53 Posted : 17 July 2009 09:10:00(UTC)
Rank: Guest
Admin

Posted By Heathrow
Especially given the price !

Admin  
#54 Posted : 18 July 2009 10:01:00(UTC)
Rank: Guest
Admin

Posted By Blue
Andy. Firstly can I say congrats on your new baby daughter and enjoy every minute cos they grow up too fast. If anything positive comes out of this it will be that the period you are out of work is at a time when your family needs you most and your relationship with your daughter gets stronger each day.

Let me see if I can help. I have interviewed many candidates recently and we don’t require the NEBOSH Diploma. CFT is right (as always) in that competence is much more important than a qualification, and the Management Regs (7) require this. So a competent person should win over a less competent person with a Diploma or Degree. However, many companies are unaware of the regulations and their ignorance of the requirements is clear in that many just want a highly qualified candidate. The amount of persons I have not taken on despite being GradIOSH, CMIOSH, etc is unreal. Their interviews went bad and knowledge a bit shaky.

You say you come across well at interview, so no problems there. Getting in front of the boss / HR manager can be tough though. If I were to offer some advice, self fund the Diploma. I know it can be expensive, but many providers will allow you to pay by interest free instalments. Your knowledge will greatly increase with the study and employers will realise you are committed. They will also have a Diploma qualified staff member eventually without having to pay for one at that level from the outset. The other bonus for employers is that you are not asking them to fund your CPD (just now). I would not worry about a Degree being required though – just move onto the next job.

TOE - FLT license do not require to be refreshed. Guidance tells us that between 3-5 years is the recommended timeframe, but not compulsory (ie – not required.) 5 years is the timeframe for passing the Diploma in full – A, B, C, and D.

I am willing to look at your CV though and give comments. Cochrane931@btinternet.com Most of the time, recruitment companies mess about with it and they can all look very similar when they arrive on the desk.

Best of luck Andy.
Admin  
#55 Posted : 18 July 2009 13:26:00(UTC)
Rank: Guest
Admin

Posted By naveen duggal
Hi, Congratulations Andy,on the arrival of your daughter. I do agree with the above comments & views of supporting your courage ,you have shown with the present circumstances,especially when you need the job....Wish You, all the best, Naveen
Admin  
#56 Posted : 19 July 2009 08:59:00(UTC)
Rank: Guest
Admin

Posted By andymak
Hi Blue and Naveen,
Thanks for your comments, as I have said before on this thread, I am in a bit of a catch 22 situation with the diploma at the moment.

It would seem I need the dip to get a job paying enough for me to self fund the dip!

If the potential temp work turns out to be more then at least I could make a start, but at the moment the DWP doesn't pay enough for me to do it even with interest free payments.

Blue, I will be in touch.
Users browsing this topic
Guest (2)
2 Pages<12
You cannot post new topics in this forum.
You cannot reply to topics in this forum.
You cannot delete your posts in this forum.
You cannot edit your posts in this forum.
You cannot create polls in this forum.
You cannot vote in polls in this forum.