In or out? I believe it was 52% in favour of out. ;)
I can see where confusion arises because the wording in the Regulations is unhelpful and they fail to provide an interpretation section.
However, I still think the HSE is very clear on this issue.
The HSE guidance groups Regs 4-6 together as one and describes the 3 stage test that applies. For clarity, that means this bit of guidance below applies to both injuries to employees and non-employees.
http://www.hse.gov.uk/riddor/key-definitions.htm'RIDDOR requires deaths and injuries to be reported only when:
there has been an accident which caused the injury
the accident was work-related
the injury is of a type which is reportable'
It does not draw any magical distinction between work-related as applied to employees and as applied to persons not at work. I don't know where that has come from in these posts. It goes on to define what work-related means and discusses the contributory nature of a failure/fault etc. Whilst RIDDOR has definite grey areas, this particular matter of whether it becomes reportable simply because it occurred whilst at work or during a work activity is not one of them.
In point of fact, here is the wording from the example being discussed:
http://www.hse.gov.uk/ri...reportable-incidents.htm'Q. An employee steps out of his private car in the office car park. In doing so, he somehow twists his ankle. As a result, he has more than seven days off work. The employee had not yet started work for the day. There were no defects to the car park surface, debris or spillages etc present that may have contributed to the incident and the light was good. Is this reportable?
A. No. Provided that there was nothing about the condition and design of the car park surface, condition, slope, weather conditions, lighting etc which contributed to the accident. Just because an accident occurs on work premises, this does not make it a work-related accident.
Note: If the injured employee was not ‘at work’ then their employer, being in control of the premises, would still have to report any work-related accident which required the injured person to be taken to a hospital for treatment. So, if the injured person put their foot in a pothole and twisted their ankle, it might be reportable as work-related. If they had just stepped awkwardly out of the car, then it is not.'
Please note the line that states 'Just because an accident occurs on work premises, this does not make it a work-related accident.' Whilst the example goes on to discuss the 'at work' issue, that is added as an addendum to the main point and you'll note is 'still' subject to the same rule of determining 'work-relatedness'. That's because the exact same set of guidance applies for Regs 4-6 inclusive.
....I knew I shouldn't get involved but can't help myself sometimes. I'll stop after this, I promise.