http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-15395168 Interesting statement from the judge but does this send out the right message? Its OK not to take safety seriously if money is tight? Yes I understand the difficulties if it sends this company under but it still does not sound right to me.

Agreed, it is a very difficult and contentious matter, exacerbated by using mainly pecuniary sanctions. It is my personal view that if an organisation is so poorly managed it should be faced with closure. Judging from the losses UK Coal have made in recent years it looks like they are on their last legs anyway. Rather than a fine it makes sense for the judge to award compensation to the bereaved dependants. The court can also impose a remedial order on the company in liaison with the regulating authorities to improve its safety systems and practices; and where applicable sanctions should be taken against directors/ senior managers ie s37 and Director Disqualification - that would send out the appropriate message.